Hold On To Stocks If They Get Quick 20% Gain Paul Whitfield Tue Feb 21, 7:00 PM ET
When a stock breaks out and races to a 20% gain within three weeks, an investor faces a choice.
Do you sell for a quick gain or sit tight for bigger gains?
IBD studies suggest that such fast movers should be held at least eight weeks. A stock that surges 20% out of the gate is showing tremendous strength.
Sometimes, though, context matters. Back in 1999, in the midst of the dot-com mania, a quick 20% gain didn't mean as much. On Oct. 14, 1999, IBD ran an article calling the quick 20% gain "a more fallible signal than in the past." Stocks were rising without any history of profits.
The investing climate is more rational today. The quick 20% gain is once again a reliable, sit-tight signal.
To give you an idea of the difference that rule makes, take a snapshot look at 2005. How many stocks on the IBD 100 list at the start of '05 shot out of a base with a quick 20% gain some time during the year? How did those stocks fare?
Among the IBD 100 stocks in the Jan. 3, 2005, issue, seven became quick 20% gainers after breakouts in '05. Only two were below that 20% gain at the eight-week mark. All went on to big gains.
Here's the score card:
Chicago Mercantile Exchange (NYSE:CME - News) broke out in June. It was up 21% in three weeks, up 38% in eight weeks and up 82% at its November high. There were corrections of 16% and 18% en route to the high.
Google (NasdaqNM:GOOG - News) broke out in October. It was up 20% in two weeks, up 31% in eight weeks and up 48% in January. It had single-digit corrections en route to its peak.
Marvell Technology (NasdaqNM:MRVL - News) broke out in November. It was up 22% in about two weeks; up 17% in eight weeks; and up 52% in January. It had single-digit corrections before reaching the summit.
Hansen Natural (NasdaqSC:HANS - News) had a breakaway gap in November. In two weeks, it was up 20% from the highest point in the gap, up 41% in eight weeks and up 80% in January. It had a 14% correction en route to its high.
Atlas America (NasdaqNM:ATLS - News) broke out in November. It was up 21% in two weeks and up 44% in eight weeks. It recently corrected about 12%.
Building Materials (NasdaqNM:BMHC - News) broke out in February 2005. It was up 20% in three weeks, up 19% in eight weeks and up 151% by October. It had several corrections of 8% to 22% en route to its apex.
Oil refiner and gas station operator Valero Energy (NYSE:VLO - News) broke out of a base-on-base Jan. 14, 2005. It then gapped up after the Martin Luther King Jr. holiday weekend on 72% higher volume (point 1).
The stock rose 23% in two weeks (point 2). In eight weeks, it was up 38%. A month later, it began a 29.5% correction (point 3). The stock then took off again and was up 145% by September (point 4). It hit a new high in early February before correcting again.
Register for free to join our community of investors and share your ideas. You will also get access to streaming quotes, interactive charts, trades, portfolio, live options flow and more tools.