These are both clear statements. There is nothing about them likely to be misunderstood. Therefore, these statements are not "gibberish." (look it up if you must) It's also clear that you disagree with them. That is not sufficient to render a clear statement gibberish. You will say my statements are wrong. That's fine. Please disagree all you like. I'll stand by those statements. I think they are both perfectly correct. Note: if you disagree with something it does not improve the board to insult the writer.