Followers | 39 |
Posts | 1624 |
Boards Moderated | 0 |
Alias Born | 04/17/2012 |
Tuesday, November 26, 2013 10:21:21 AM
Jury: Newegg infringes Spangenberg patent, must pay $2.3 million
Determined lawyers—and the father of modern crypto—couldn't stop TQP patent.
by Joe Mullin - Nov 26, 2013 5:20 am UTC
MARSHALL, TX—Newegg, an online retailer that has made a name for itself fighting the non-practicing patent holders sometimes called "patent trolls," sits on the losing end of a lawsuit tonight. An eight-person jury came back shortly after 7:00pm and found that the company infringed all four asserted claims of a patent owned by TQP Development, a company owned by patent enforcement expert Erich Spangenberg.
The jury also found that the patent was valid, apparently rejecting arguments by famed cryptographer Whitfield Diffie. Diffie took the stand on Friday to argue on behalf of Newegg and against the patent.
In total, the jury ordered Newegg to pay $2.3 million, a bit less than half of the $5.1 million TQP's damage expert suggested.
Deliberations immediately followed closing arguments and lasted just over three hours. The lawyers from both teams took in the verdict without emotion and shook hands following the verdict.
TQP's single patent is tied to a failed modem business run by Michael Jones, formerly president of Telequip. The company has acquired more than $45 million in patent licensing fees by getting settlements from a total of 139 companies. TQP argues that the patent covers SSL or TLS combined with the RC4 cipher, a common Internet security system used by retailers like Newegg.
We asked Jones if he had anything to share on the verdict. "I feel fortunate to live in a country with a judicial system like this where a jury can decide these things," he said.
With that, both sides left the courtroom and walked into Marshall's central square. The weather shifted dramatically since the beginning of trial, and it was cold and rainy then.
The Newegg team was obviously crestfallen. But Newegg Chief Legal Officer Lee Cheng—who has said he will appeal any loss at this trial—made a point of congratulating the inventor after the verdict. "Congratulations Mr. Jones," he said. Cheng then added with a smile: "Get your money up front."
Three Hour Wait
There were several quiet periods during the wait for a verdict. Immediately after closing arguments, lawyers from both sides shook hands and congratulated each other on a case well argued. Cheng and Spangenberg, who had not met in person before this trial, spoke quietly for several minutes at that point. Both appeared friendly.
Outside in the rain, I spoke briefly to Spangenberg. The patent expert apparently read some earlier Ars coverage. "Did I really say I didn't think he [Cheng] was very smart?" (I assured him he had, as I had double-checked my notes.) The interview had come during a tense period of the litigation back in August.
"I must have been in a bad mood that day," said Spangenberg. "I do think he's a smart guy—he went to Harvard and Berkeley—and I think he's a nice guy."
Spangenberg had to leave town for other business, as did lead TQP lawyer Marc Fenster. Neither were immediately available for further comment on the verdict.
The wait dragged on. As the hour neared 6:00pm, US District Judge Rodney Gilstrap came out, dressed simply in a blue shirt without his black robe, and spoke to the parties. "Well, what do y'all think? Will we get a verdict tonight?" he asked. Yes, most people thought so. The talk turned to football, what the parties thought of Marshall, and additional small talk. "However it turns out, I hope both sides feel like you got a fair trial," said Gilstrap. Lawyers on both sides nodded dutifully.
At 7:15pm, the judge told the assembled lawyers he'd give the jurors until 7:30pm, and then he might ask if they wanted to come back the following morning. Courthouse security and staff were surely eager to go home. But several minutes later, he got word from his clerk that a verdict had been reached.
Leaving town
Back at their hotel on the edge of town, Cheng and his team were packing their things and preparing to drive to Dallas. He sat down with Ars in the lobby.
"We're certainly very disappointed," said Cheng. "We respectfully disagree with the verdict that the jury reached tonight. We fully intend, as we did in the Soverain case, to take this case up on appeal and vindicate our rights."
Soverain was the "shopping cart" patent that Newegg was ordered to pay $2.5 million for, but the company then knocked it out on appeal. Soverain's damage request was huge for Newegg: $34 million.
All Newegg cases are budgeted for appeal from the start, Cheng said. Appellate lawyer Ed Reines, who represented Newegg in its other two patent appeal wins, had been present in the courtroom for much of the TQP trial.
"Of course, we would have preferred to go up as the respondent," Cheng said. "But I'm not going to be upset or unduly disappointed about this. Our team did the best work we could do. We did what we felt in our hearts was right.
Look, I could have lost my job if Soverain had won. $34 million is material to Newegg. I could have taken the path of least resistance. I could have said, 'Everyone else did the same thing, so we're no worse off than anyone else.' But we couldn't afford to pay people off the way some of our competitors were paying. We had to do something different. And it's the right thing to do."
"This was a pivotal case that we could not settle," Cheng said. "Mr. Spangenberg has sued us three times."
TQP has pending litigation against more than a dozen other companies. Google, LinkedIn, and Sony are all scheduled for trials, in the same court, in early 2014. The law firm that represents Google had various lawyers around throughout the Newegg trial as well to observe and take notes.
As Cheng talked with us, his other lawyers left. Diffie, Newegg's star witness and the co-inventor of public key cryptography, was riding with Cheng and waited for him. His packed bags sat next to him as he worked on his Mac laptop in the hotel lobby. I asked how he was feeling.
"Distressed," he said. "I was hoping to be rid of this business."
With that, he followed Cheng into the parking lot. They began the long journey, first to Dallas and ultimately back to California.
Recent MARA News
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 09/21/2024 01:20:08 AM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 09/21/2024 01:20:06 AM
- Form 144 - Report of proposed sale of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 09/16/2024 03:18:33 PM
- Form 144 - Report of proposed sale of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 09/16/2024 03:07:10 PM
- Grayscale Launches XRP Fund, Coinbase Debuts cbBTC Token, 1inch Reveals Atomic Swap Protocol • IH Market News • 09/12/2024 07:02:06 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 09/10/2024 08:35:41 PM
- Form 8-K - Current report • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 09/10/2024 08:30:11 PM
- Form 3 - Initial statement of beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 09/06/2024 09:13:40 PM
- Form 3 - Initial statement of beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 09/06/2024 09:11:38 PM
- Form 8-K - Current report • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 09/05/2024 12:35:59 PM
- MARA Announces Bitcoin Production and Mining Operation Updates for August 2024 • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 09/04/2024 12:05:00 PM
- Bitcoin Surges Following Powell Speech; Sony Launches Soneium Blockchain; JPMorgan Cuts Miners’ Price Targets • IH Market News • 08/23/2024 07:49:31 PM
- Bitcoin and Ethereum ETFs See Low Volume, FLOKI Gains 8%, State Street Launches Digital Asset Platform • IH Market News • 08/20/2024 07:30:32 PM
- Bitcoin Fall Hits Other Tokens, MicroStrategy Launches Leveraged ETF, Mintzberg Takes Over Grayscale Leadership • IH Market News • 08/15/2024 07:35:02 PM
- Form 8-K - Current report • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 08/14/2024 09:27:28 PM
- Marathon Digital Holdings, Inc. Completes $300 Million Offering of 2.125% Convertible Senior Notes Due 2031, Purchases $249 Million of Bitcoin • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 08/14/2024 09:25:00 PM
- Marathon Defies Globalization with ‘Made in USA’ Bitcoin, Mt. Gox Wallet Tests Transaction, and Latest in Crypto • IH Market News • 08/13/2024 07:35:36 PM
- Form 8-K - Current report • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 08/13/2024 10:08:26 AM
- Marathon Digital Holdings, Inc. Announces Pricing of Oversubscribed Offering of Convertible Senior Notes • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 08/13/2024 01:41:00 AM
- LDO, GLM, SUI, APT, AZERO on the Radar; Marathon Digital Seeks $250M for Bitcoin Expansion, and More • IH Market News • 08/12/2024 07:47:40 PM
- Marathon Digital Holdings, Inc. Announces Proposed Private Offering of $250 Million of Convertible Senior Notes • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 08/12/2024 11:00:00 AM
VHAI - Vocodia Partners with Leading Political Super PACs to Revolutionize Fundraising Efforts • VHAI • Sep 19, 2024 11:48 AM
Dear Cashmere Group Holding Co. AKA Swifty Global Signs Binding Letter of Intent to be Acquired by Signing Day Sports • DRCR • Sep 19, 2024 10:26 AM
HealthLynked Launches Virtual Urgent Care Through Partnership with Lyric Health. • HLYK • Sep 19, 2024 8:00 AM
Element79 Gold Corp. Appoints Kevin Arias as Advisor to the Board of Directors, Strengthening Strategic Leadership • ELMGF • Sep 18, 2024 10:29 AM
Mawson Finland Limited Further Expands the Known Mineralized Zones at Rajapalot: Palokas step-out drills 7 metres @ 9.1 g/t gold & 706 ppm cobalt • MFL • Sep 17, 2024 9:02 AM
PickleJar Announces Integration With OptCulture to Deliver Holistic Fan Experiences at Venue Point of Sale • PKLE • Sep 17, 2024 8:00 AM