XpresSpa Group Inc (XSPA)

[coolerheadsprevail]

First, the 2003 date has nothing to do with when any type of infringement occurred. Constructive knowledge is claimed to have been obtained in 2003 for 420. When infringement actually occurred is unknown -- even to edva.

Bringing up the specific 2003 date in the context of a discussion about damages and the trebling of such damages is irrelevant as the date of constructive knowledge has no bearing on it -- it is the date that infringement began.

And in your original post, the clear inference was that the trebling could potentially go back to 2003 -- this is how JJSeabrook inferred it as well, which is why he replied the way he did, and once again, which is why I initially posted my concurrence with JJ's statement.