mailhot72 Wednesday, 11/14/12 11:43:29 AM Re: nealgalt1 post# 175 Post # of 179 I don't think you can go wrong with either company, long term. I always felt there was more upside and potential with TIE, as I felt the would capture more of the potential market in the future. RTI is solid and has upside of $28 - $30 range from current PPS (up 20% long term) has maintained $20 PPS for last 3 years. Downside is a lot of dumping has occurred over last 6 months. ATI seems a bit more risky to me at this time. It is like a falling knife right now. Do you really want to try and catch it?? Their revenue dropped a substantial amount resulting in continous drop in PPS. The outlook for 4Q 2012, doesn't look much better. Their current PPS is at a low point that it hasn't been at in almost 4 years. It is now at its lowest PPS in 3 years. Granted this is due to bounce back, the question remains, when?? This was once a $80 - $100 stock. Can it get back there in the long term and bring us some ROI, IMHO, I believe so, but maybe not that high ($40 range), but when will it hit bottom??? This stock is worth 1/2 what it was a year ago. They are at a fragile point now. Your thoughts????