Home > Boards > Free Zone > User's Groups > Golden Jackass Tobacco Shop

The Fallacies of this war.

Public Reply | Private Reply | Keep | Last ReadPost New MsgReplies (2) | Next 10 | Previous | Next
TigerPaw Member Profile
Member Level 
Followed By 0
Posts 23
Boards Moderated 0
Alias Born 02/06/01
160x600 placeholder
Top Stories of the Day
TOP STORIES Restaurant Brands More Than Doubles 2Q Profit, Increases Buyback Authorization
Walt Disney to Require U.S. Employees to be Vaccinated
Top Company News of the Day
J&J Won't Be Held Liable For Illinois Woman's Death in Talc Case -- Reuters
Norfolk Southern Raises Quarterly Dividend by 10 Cents to $1.09/Share
Front Month Nymex RBOB Gasoline Rose 5.41% This Month to Settle at $2.3659 -- Data Talk
Front Month Nymex Natural Gas Rose 7.23% This Month to Settle at $3.9140 -- Data Talk
Soybeans Slide as Traders Liquidate -- Daily Grain Highlights
Regeneron Gets Expanded EUA for Covid-19 Antibody Cocktail -- Update
Regeneron Gets Expanded EUA for Covid-19 Antibody Cocktail
Unemployment Rate Seen Ticking Down to 5.7% -- Data Week Ahead
Gopuff Reaches $15 Billion Valuation With $1 Billion From Blackstone, SoftBank and Others
EURO STOXX 50 Index Ends the Month 0.62% Higher at 4089.30 -- Data Talk
FTSE 100 Index Ends the Month 0.07% Lower at 7032.30 -- Data Talk
STOXX Europe 600 Index Ends the Month 1.97% Higher at 461.74 -- Data Talk
DAX Ends the Month 0.09% Higher at 15544.39 -- Data Talk
STOXX Europe 50 Index Ends the Month 1.23% Higher at 3555.81 -- Data Talk
London Shares End Month With Mixed Results
Colgate-Palmolive On Pace for Largest Percent Decrease Since March 2020 -- Data Talk
Caterpillar Worst Performer in the DJIA So Far Today -- Data Talk
Amazon.com Down Over 7%, on Pace for Largest Percent Decrease Since May 2020 -- Data Talk
ArcelorMittal, Canada Government to Invest $1.42 Billion in Carbon-Cutting Technology
Caterpillar Reports Favorable Currency Impact on 2Q Sales -- Currency Comment
Daimler Management, Board Approve Truck Spinoff
Chicago Business Barometer Rises in July
U.S. Personal Spending +1.0% in June -- Update
U.S. Personal Spending +1.0% in June
TigerPaw Member Level  Saturday, 03/01/03 03:00:12 PM
Re: TigerPaw post# 784
Post # of 795 
The Fallacies of this war.

The Bush administration is advancing the cause of their war by using a series of logical fallacies. A fallacy is, very generally, an error in reasoning. This differs from a factual error, which is simply being wrong about the facts. To be more specific, a fallacy is an "argument" in which the premises given for the conclusion do not provide the needed degree of support.

Probably the most used logical fallacy used in support of the war is the fallacy of Misleading Vividness. This is the fallacy of letting a single strong example or a single vivid case to outweigh strong statistical data. The vivid case of course is the terrorist attack of 9/11. This fallacy is used in support of not only Bush's war, but almost every other action he has taken in the last year. The response to this dramatic TV footage of the towers is way out of proportion to the actual dangers or consequences implied in the actions taken since then.

When it comes to justifying this specific Iraqi incarnation of their war, the administration used several other logical fallacies to confuse the public. In the fallacy of Begging the Question the premises includes the claim that the conclusion is true or (directly or indirectly) assume that the conclusion is true. This is commonly seen in the Rumsfeld & Bush claim that Saddam must have weapons hidden because the inspectors have not found them yet. Implied in the premise is the conclusion that there are weapons to be found. In actually the claims say nothing about the presence of weapons while the inspectors say at least something factual on the subject.

This argument is further confused by the fallacy of Special Pleading. This is the fallacy of failing the present a reason why this case should be considered differently from other similar cases.
http://www.nixoncenter.org/010502Is%20North%20Korea%20More%20Dangerous%20than%20Iraq.htm .
or even from the case of the arguer. http://www.salon.com/news/col/scheer/2002/12/11/weapons/ .

The Bandwagon is a fallacy in which a threat of rejection by one's peers (or peer pressure) is substituted for evidence in an "argument." The Bush administration does this domestically with their accusations that all who question their war are un-American. http://www.newsfrombabylon.com/article.php?sid=1355 . Internationally the fallacy is extended to the point of outright threats. http://www.cnn.com/2001/US/11/06/gen.attack.on.terror/ . None of these threats or appeals to polls provides any justification for Bush's war; they only convey his threats and perhaps reasons to worry about confrontation with Bush himself.

The Bush administration deflects the more measured responses in a fallacy known as the Excluded Middle where it is claimed that if a war with Iraq is not begun, and begun soon, then nothing will be done and Saddam will get mass weapons and destroy the world. The fallacy completely ignores any other possible actions besides war or nothing. http://www.theage.com.au/articles/2003/02/09/1044725672665.html .

While the Bush administration uses a great many fallacies, such as Appeal to Emotion, Poisoning the Well, and Burden of Proof, probably the most used false justification for Bush's war is Guilt by Association in which the crimes of terrorist Osama Bin Laden are associated with Saddam Hussein by the irrelevant fact of their Muslim heritage.


Public Reply | Private Reply | Keep | Last ReadPost New MsgReplies (2) | Next 10 | Previous | Next
Follow Board Follow Board Keyboard Shortcuts Report TOS Violation
Current Price
Detailed Quote - Discussion Board
Intraday Chart
+/- to Watchlist
Consent Preferences