I see your point mikey, really do, that whatever funds we would get are from others that they have stolen from or deceived (i.e. Blood money)
But it is the only way!
If you want to stop this it simply must become unprofitable, and very expensive for those who wish to pursue it.
The only way to accomplish that is by making the penalty and payment as extreme as possible.
Giving away a percentage of those gains to charity, in whichever way you decide, would be a most gracious act, and I would say alleviate a person of whatever guilt that could be placed on them by receiving gains in this way, as they were gotten from efforts that are stopping any one else from being hurt in the same way...
The thing is this must stop, and it won't until there is a real price to pay for doing.
"no law ever written, however noble, ever stopped one crime, until it is enforced and acted on"
"evil flourishes when good people fail to act"