IMF head denied bail in sexual assault case; France in shock
Dominique Strauss-Kahn will remain in custody in New York as he faces charges that he sexually assaulted a chambermaid. In France, some speculate the case could be a set-up to torpedo the Socialist leader's political career. Others say they have faith in American justice.
By Nathaniel Popper and Kim Willsher, Los Angeles Times
May 17, 2011
Reporting from New York and Paris
Advertisement
As Dominique Strauss-Kahn was denied bail on sexual assault charges in New York City, the International Monetary Fund head's native France, and European financial markets, continued to reel over the lurid allegations that could result in a 25-year prison sentence.
The French Socialist Party leader, ordered Monday by a Manhattan judge to remain in jail until his next court hearing, faces a probable end to his aspirations to seek the French presidency.
He also faces the prospects of additional sexual assault investigation, into a 2002 encounter with a French writer and journalist, Tristane Banon, three decades his junior. A lawyer for the woman said she would file an official complaint charging that she had to fight him off and that now "she knows she'll be heard."
Meanwhile, stocks fell in Europe, where Strauss-Kahn has been a key player in helping the continent work its way through the debt crisis involving nations such as Greece, Portugal and Spain. He had been scheduled to attend an important meeting of European finance ministers in Brussels beginning Monday.
Instead, Strauss-Kahn, 62, was in a Manhattan courtroom, looking grim as he stood next to his lawyer in his first court appearance since his arrest Saturday on charges of assaulting a maid in his Sofitel hotel suite near Times Square.
The burgeoning scandal, involving a longtime politician who has been known both as a brilliant economist and a womanizer, has led to soul-searching among some in France over the nation's seemingly laissez-faire attitude toward its leaders' sexual peccadilloes.
"Politicians and artists enjoy a particular tolerance on this subject," wrote Nicolas Demorand, editor of the Liberation daily newspaper. "Part of the shock comes also from the unusual scene, until now unthinkable here: police arresting a top-level politician on a matter of morals."
Others in France said they could easily imagine Strauss-Kahn having sex with a 32-year-old chambermaid in his $3,000-a-night hotel suite, but could not believe he would force himself on her.
"Seduction, yes, but no way would he use constraint or violence," said Jean-Marie Le Guen, a Socialist Party lawmaker who has known him for 25 years. "A certain number of facts, and certain aspects of the story we are hearing from the press make this not credible," he told France-Inter radio.
Le Guen said his friend knew he would be the target of mudslinging when he suggested he might run for president, but added: "What they are asking us to believe... it's just hallucinations. I'm a doctor and I know this can happen."
At the 27-minute court hearing, Strauss-Kahn's lawyer, Benjamin Brafman, entered a not-guilty plea on four felony counts, including sexual abuse and attempted rape, and three misdemeanor accounts, including unlawful imprisonment. The defendant did not speak.
Brafman, in seeking bail, rejected any possibility of Strauss-Kahn being a flight risk, even though he had been arrested on an airplane about to leave for France at John F. Kennedy Airport. The lawyer said his client's departure had been long scheduled and "there is no indication, nothing, nothing that he intends to flee."
But the prosecution convinced Judge Melissa C. Jackson otherwise. Assistant District Atty. John A. McConnell contended that Strauss-Kahn had "a substantial incentive to flee" and that the maid had provided "a very powerful and detailed account" that was corroborated by forensic evidence.
The next court hearing is expected to be held later this week.
In Paris, some politicians and commentators said the affair was a "disgrace" and a "humiliation" to the nation, describing France as the "real victim." Others launched a vigorous defense of Strauss-Kahn, saying the incident may have been a set-up by political rivals.
Conspiracy theories swept the nation after it was revealed that the person who broke the news in France via Twitter, was a member of Nicolas Sarkozy's ruling center-right party. Jonathan Pinet said he got the information from "a pal in the United States," but some web users accused him of being part of a smear operation "orchestrated in minute detail" by the country's leaders.
Strauss-Kahn himself broached the possibility of a looming set-up in an interview with the left-wing daily paper Liberation three weeks ago, the paper reported. He said he thought he was under surveillance and cited three difficulties he might face if he were to run for president: "Money, women and the fact I am Jewish."
"Yes, I like women...so what?" he said, adding that he might fall victim to an invented scandal.
"A woman raped in a car park and who's been promised 500,000 or a million euros to invent such a story..."
Strauss-Kahn's lawyers in Paris claimed that he had left the Sofitel hotel in midtown Manhattan about midday on Saturday, an hour before the attack was said to have taken place. They told journalists that he had lunch with his daughter, a student at Columbia University, before heading for JFK airport. En route, he realized he had left a cellphone at the hotel and called reception to ask employees to find it for him.
New York police were able to track Strauss-Kahn and arrest him thanks to the phone call he made to the hotel, according to this account.
The maid has said that when she entered Strauss-Kahn's room to clean it, he came out of the bathroom naked, pushed her onto a bed and assaulted her, New York police said. At Monday's hearing, prosecutor McConnell said that Strauss-Kahn attempted to rape her and when that failed, he forced her to perform oral sex.
McConnell also said that Strauss-Kahn had a history of improper sexual behavior, referring to "at least one" other incident that occurred abroad, leading observers to conclude it was the complaint by the French writer, Banon, goddaughter to one of Strauss-Kahn's former wives,
The maid later picked the IMF head out of a lineup at a Harlem police precinct. Local news reports said the woman was a 32-year-old single mother from Ghana. DNA samples taken from the maid and Strauss-Kahn were brought to the Manhattan Special Victims Unit in Harlem for testing.
Some French commentators criticized American media coverage of the case, alleging that the presumption of innocence had been repeatedly breached by photos taken as he was led in handcuffs out of a New York police facility.
The pictures amounted to "unsupportable cruelty", said Manuel Valls, one leading French Socialist.
Another French politician, Jean-Pierre Chevenement, said Strauss-Kahn was the victim of a "horrifying international lynching" based on weak evidence.
Not all agreed with such assessments. "I have confidence in American justice," said French ecology and transport minister, Nathalie Kosciusko-Morizet. "It's so French to see conspiracies everywhere, it's something I believe that's in our culture."
Strauss-Kahn will be held alone, segregated from other inmates for his own protection, at New York City's Riker's Island prison, on the East River. The prison is used primarily for short-term detainees and is a far cry from Strauss-Kahn's chic $4 million Paris apartment, the brick mansion he uses in Georgetown, near IMF headquarters in Washington, and the hotel suite on West 44th Street where the alleged attack took place.
AI
