Home > Boards > The Lounge > Hobbies > GUNS/BARMS (GUNS)

Rosie O'Donnell's use of Kellerman's facts are debunked

Public Reply | Private Reply | Keep | Last ReadPost New MsgNext 10 | Previous | Next
ONEBGG Member Profile
Member Level Grandfathered Member
Followed By 133
Posts 113,358
Boards Moderated 20
Alias Born 03/05/01
160x600 placeholder
ONEBGG Member Level Grandfathered Member Saturday, 07/06/02 08:10:40 PM
Re: None
Post # of 37748 
Rosie O'Donnell's use of Kellerman's facts are debunked

From Yahoo Gun Groups:

First, of all, since Gary Kleck's study says that guns are used from 600,000 to 3 million times a year in self defense(usual number stated is 2.5 million), and that there are 35,000 deaths(I believe) caused by a person with a gun a year, than at worst, you are 17:1 times more likely to defend yourself than die because of it, and at best 86.1 times more likely, with the probable ratio of 71:1.

Second, of all, the only area Kellermann studied was King County, Washington State. How can Seattle represent the whole country? If I studied Washington Dc, and then Livingston County Michigan, there would be much different results.

Third, Kellermann used a CASE-CONTROL study. These types of studies are often highly flawed. He even hinted that case-control was not the best way to conduct a study, but said that other types are not fesible.

Here's information on problems with case-control studies. http://www.extramural.uiuc.edu/ana/Rehab401/6-20-design/tsld001.htm
There are three or four slides there. I only have some basic statistical knowledge, so I had to search hard to find something in layman's terms that avg people like me can understand.

I'm posting several debunkings, some biased, some neutral.
Here are the debunk links.

Kellermann admits error. http://www.nejm.org/content/1998/0339/0013/0928b.asp

Letters to the editor and replies. http://www.nejm.org/content/1994/0330/0005/0365.asp

Edgar Suter - National Chair Doctors for Integrity in Policy Research, Inc. http://www.dipr.org/content/papers/guns_in_the_medical_literature.html
(neutral debunking)

There are other articles from this site as well. http://www.dipr.org/
http://www.i2i.org/SuptDocs/Crime/43_to_1_fallacy.htm - Dave Kopel(slightly Biased), sites Dr Kleck of FSU

http://www.goal.org/articles/coveystats.html - Biased organazation(Gun owners action league), but this article was from Carneige Mellon University.

http://www.2ndlawlib.org/journals/tennmed.html Don B Kates and others on the "Public Health" aspect as relates to Kellerman. As seen in the Tennessee Law Review.

PS - As of 10:34 TODAY!

The Gun Defense Clock. Every 13 seconds an American firearm owner uses a firearm in defense against a criminal.

Criminal attacks stopped by guns this year:

" + defenses + "
"); document.write("Gun defenses since January 1, 2002.
"); document.write("Date and Time Now: "); document.write(dayStr); document.write("
"); // -- done hiding from old browsers --

Gun defenses since January 1, 2002.
Date and Time Now: Thursday, July 04, 2002 10:34:42 AM

Note: Also posted on BARMS.

Freedom Is An Ongoing & Everlasting Battle!!!


Public Reply | Private Reply | Keep | Last ReadPost New MsgNext 10 | Previous | Next
Follow Board Follow Board Keyboard Shortcuts Report TOS Violation
Current Price
Detailed Quote - Discussion Board
Intraday Chart
+/- to Watchlist