Monday, January 26, 2009 3:12:36 PM
by: Christopher Whalen January 26, 2009
Christopher Whalen (Seeking Alpha)
Banking bailouts were sold to us as a "necessary evil" because we were told only our existing network of banks could irrigate the economy with cash and so rescue industry. Now we know they can't do that because their legacy absorbs all the resources, it would appear more sensible to let the old banks fail and start a new generation of banks. After all, the best credit risk is the institution that has no debt. So you could say the error wasn't to let Lehman collapse, but not to have allowed all the banks to collapse in order to have a fresh start. And right now the job market has plenty of bankers available to set up and run new institutions. With just a quarter of the $800 billion or so already splashed about you could start a whole new Wall St. It's not a matter of saying "no more banking system" but "no more fatally compromised old banking system burdened with structural insolvency." (Ban)king is dead. long live (ban)king.
-- A reader of The IRA
The term "bad bank" is being tossed around Washington dinner tables this week, a sign that the situation facing the largest banks is reaching a boiling point. It is amazing to us to see how little people understand the choices facing us with the big banks, how narrow those choices truly are and how the numbers in terms of losses are so BIG that they will ultimately force us to do the right thing. A couple of points:
First, IRA's estimate for accumulated bank charge offs for 2009 is in the neighborhood of $1 trillion vs. $1.5 trillion in Tier 1 Risk Based Capital at all US banks today. Good news, though, is that 2/3 to 2/4 of that loss number comes from the top four - Citigroup (C), Bank of America (BAC), JPMorganChase (JPM) and Wells Fargo (WFC), in that order of risk profile.
Since most of the toxicity in the banking system is concentrated among the larger banks, perhaps we can rebuild the industry using the next round of TARP funds to bulk up these relatively smaller banks and thereby end up with 10-15 larger super regionals in the $300-$500 billion asset range. There may even be banks of this size still doing business under the current names of C, JPM, BAC, etc, but these new banks will have new owners and creditors.
Second, the Good Bank/Bad Bank debate is really a political battle between the large banks listed above plus Goldman Sachs (GS) and Morgan Stanley (MS) et al among the Sell Side survivors in NYC vs. the rest of the industry and the US economy. In preparing their plans for review by the White House, we hear that the Fed and OCC are supporting further bailouts for the larger banks, while the rest of the industry is being resolved and recapitalized a la Washington Mutual and Lehman Brothers.
Perhaps we ought to feed the "good bank" parts of the "too big to fail" crowd, a crowd prone to leverage and bad risk management, to the smaller and plain vanilla bankers that comprise the nominal majority of the industry. This would solve many things including reducing the lobbying power that Wall Street has in Washington. Come to think of it, President Obama should think about banning lobbying by any company participating in the TARP.
Remember that the entire banking industry stands in front of the taxpayers in terms of loss absorption at the FDIC, so you can understand why the smaller banks in the industry are SERIOUSLY PISSED OFF at the large banks and their minions in the Obama Administration like Tim Geithner and Robert Rubin. Oh, and don't forget Chairman Ben Bernanke and the entire Fed board of governors. These leading officials are increasingly talking the side of the large banks in the battle over limited financial resources, a fact that is causing the community bankers to rise in anger. Stay tuned.
Third, juxtapose the Fed/OCC position of 'let's bail out the big banks' (equity and debt) which Tim Geithner established in the Bear Stearns and AIG rescues, and reiterated in his confirmation testimony, with the modified "tough love" position of Sheila Bair, where she proposes to buy bad assets from the Big Four Zombies w/o a resolution. It seems clear that both sides of the equation in Washington are prepared to socialize the large bank losses and in particular subsidize the bond holders at public expense, an act of generosity that could cost the industry and taxpayers another $1 trillion before all is said and done.
But at least with the modified tough love proposed by Bair, the US government still would clearly end up as the explicit owner and the existing equity and preferred would be diluted out of existence as the quid pro quo for the bad asset purchases. That is the little detail people in Washington still don't understand. Indeed, if you think about C as perhaps accounting for one third of the $1 trillion IRA charge off estimate, then Washington must impose a haircut on debt or ask the banking industry and the taxpayer to subsidize the loss.
The better course for the economy outside NYC is to resolve these large institutions over the course of 2009 and beyond, first by diluting the equity (common and preferred) and effecting a conservatorship a la Fannie/Freddie. This eliminates the issue for the markets. A formal open bank assistance might be a default under the ISDA contract template, something the Fed's conflicted Mandarins would not initially accept, but when the charge-offs at C rise above total risk based capital and keep rising, perhaps minds in DC will begin to change. Then we can haircut the Big Four Bank debt in a negotiated deal pre-receivership, and sell the non M2M bank assets and liabilities to stronger hands. This is the traditional American way of dealing with insolvency in the absence of political meddling by the Fed and the Congress. Let Sheila Bair and the FDIC do the job and we can make the economy rebound with surprising speed. It only takes political courage. We have the money.
Recent WFC News
- Positive Reaction To Inflation Data, Bank Earnings Leads To Strength On Wall Street • IH Market News • 10/11/2024 08:45:13 PM
- Futures Pointing To Roughly Flat Open On Wall Street • IH Market News • 10/11/2024 01:05:24 PM
- Wells Fargo Reports Third Quarter 2024 Financial Results • Business Wire • 10/11/2024 11:03:00 AM
- U.S. Index Futures Dip Ahead of Bank Earnings and Inflation Report • IH Market News • 10/11/2024 10:33:14 AM
- Neurodiversity workshops to be delivered at no cost to corporate America through UConn and Wells Fargo collaboration • PR Newswire (US) • 10/10/2024 02:01:00 PM
- Elena M. Gallo Named Government Banking Division Executive • Business Wire • 10/08/2024 02:02:00 PM
- Wells Fargo to Announce Third Quarter 2024 Earnings on Oct. 11, 2024 • Business Wire • 10/04/2024 12:00:00 PM
- Wells Fargo Donates More Than $1 Million For Hurricane Helene Disaster Relief • Business Wire • 10/01/2024 12:40:00 PM
- Apollo Eyes $5 Billion Investment in Intel; TSMC and Samsung Explore UAE Chip Projects, and More • IH Market News • 09/23/2024 10:32:25 AM
- Wells Fargo Bank Decreases Prime Rate to 8.00 Percent • Business Wire • 09/18/2024 08:45:00 PM
- Wells Fargo Expands API Capabilities for its Commercial Banking Business • Business Wire • 09/17/2024 01:30:00 PM
- Volkswagen Financial Services U.S. and Wells Fargo announce cooperation agreement for vehicle purchase financing of Volkswagen, Audi, and Ducati brands in the United States • PR Newswire (US) • 09/16/2024 05:00:00 PM
- OpenAI Unveils Strawberry AI Model Series; Boeing Stock Falls 4% Amid Strike; HR Surges 20% on Growth Forecast • IH Market News • 09/13/2024 10:12:55 AM
- Wells Fargo Issues Statement on Agreement with OCC • Business Wire • 09/12/2024 06:08:00 PM
- Andrew Barnes Joins Wells Fargo Commercial Banking Team to Lead the Military and Veteran Segment • Business Wire • 09/12/2024 03:00:00 PM
- EBONY is Bringing the Ultimate HBCU Experience to Atlanta with Inaugural Yard Fest in Partnership with Wells Fargo and 300 Entertainment • PR Newswire (US) • 09/09/2024 01:00:00 PM
- Wells Fargo to Present at the Barclays Global Financial Services Conference • Business Wire • 09/03/2024 12:00:00 PM
- Wells Fargo Reaffirms Commitment as Official Bank Sponsor for the 2024 Orange Blossom Classic • PR Newswire (US) • 08/30/2024 12:33:00 PM
- Walmart Sells JD.com Stake, Microchip Suffers Cyberattack, Union Pacific Warns of Strike in Canada, and Latest News • IH Market News • 08/21/2024 12:12:11 PM
- Trimont Signs Definitive Agreement to Acquire Wells Fargo Non-Agency Third-Party Commercial Mortgage Servicing Business • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 08/20/2024 01:16:00 PM
- Wells Fargo Enters into Agreement with Trimont to Sell the Non-Agency Third-Party Servicing Segment of its Commercial Mortgage Servicing Business • Business Wire • 08/20/2024 01:15:00 PM
- FuboTV Soars 12% After Venu Sports Block, Goldman Sachs Lowers U.S. Recession Odds, BHP Ends Chile Strike • IH Market News • 08/19/2024 09:28:19 AM
- Wells Fargo & Company Declares Cash Dividends on Preferred Stock • Business Wire • 08/16/2024 12:00:00 PM
- ASML Rises 7% on Export Waiver; Intel Plans Layoffs, HSBC $3B Buyback Announced, and More • IH Market News • 07/31/2024 09:55:50 AM
- Bridget Engle to Join Wells Fargo as Head of Technology; Tracy Kerrins to Lead Consumer Technology and Generative AI Teams • Business Wire • 07/30/2024 08:00:00 PM
ZenaTech, Inc. (NASDAQ: ZENA) Launchs IQ Nano Drone for Commercial Indoor Use • HALO • Oct 10, 2024 8:09 AM
CBD Life Sciences Inc. (CBDL) Targets Alibaba as the Next Retail Giant for Wholesale Expansion of Top-Selling CBD Products • CBDL • Oct 10, 2024 8:00 AM
Foremost Lithium Announces Option Agreement with Denison on 10 Uranium Projects Spanning over 330,000 Acres in the Athabasca Basin, Saskatchewan • FAT • Oct 10, 2024 5:51 AM
Element79 Gold Corp. Reports Significant Progress in Community Relations and Development Efforts in Chachas, Peru • ELEM • Oct 9, 2024 10:30 AM
Unitronix Corp Launches Share Buyback Initiative • UTRX • Oct 9, 2024 9:10 AM
BASANITE INDUSTRIES, LLC RECEIVES U.S. PATENT FOR ITS BASAFLEX™ BASALT FIBER COMPOSITE REBAR AND METHOD OF MANUFACTURING • BASA • Oct 9, 2024 7:30 AM