mflutie, I believe the "issue" most folks have with the gentleman in question, is his inability to even MENTION a stock he is at loss in - when questioned by those monitoring and perhaps trading on his alerts.
I think you've already touched on the topic last week or so, when commenting about how certain posters seem to go into hiding when a trade goes against them, even though many people are asking if that poster was infact, still holding the position.
I think you see my point..
I hope others do as well.
It's simply "bad form", and perhaps one of the reasons that folks are doing a mass exodus from that other site.