Fact check: Trump-backed Michigan congressional candidate John Gibbs falsely claims 2020 election had ‘mathematically impossible’ anomalies
Republican Michigan congressional candidate John Gibbs is falsely claiming that the 2020 election results could not possibly be correct – and citing irrelevant statistical tidbits as his supposed evidence.
“I think when you look at the results of the 2020 election, there are anomalies in there, to put it very lightly, that are simply mathematically impossible,” Gibbs said during a televised roundtable discussion that aired this past weekend on WOOD TV8 of Grand Rapids.
Gibbs has the endorsement of former President Donald Trump. He is a former US Department of Housing and Urban Development official who is trying to unseat incumbent Rep. Peter Meijer, who voted to impeach Trump after the 2021 insurrection at the Capitol, in the Republican congressional primary in Michigan’s 3rd District.
To justify his “simply mathematically impossible” claim, Gibbs cited two pieces of supposed evidence that are not evidence at all
First, like Trump has since 2020, Gibbs talked about Trump’s performance in so-called bellwether counties – the small list of counties that had for decades been won by the presidential candidate who also won the presidency. “A bellwether county,” Gibbs said, “is a county such that whichever candidate wins it, they won the election with 100% predictability. Well, President Trump won almost every single bellwether county but still ended up losing the election somehow, which is very anomalous to say the least.”
Next, Gibbs pointed to the fact that Trump got more votes in the 2020 election he lost than he did in the 2016 election he won.
“Usually – actually, always – if a presidential candidate gets more votes the second time than (the) first time, you always win,” Gibbs said. “But President Trump got something like 15-20% more votes than he got the first time yet still lost, which is probably mathematically impossible – certainly unprecedented in history.”
Gibbs has made this latter claim in even stronger language in the past, claiming in an April interview that it was “almost certainly mathematically impossible” for Trump to have lost in 2020 while improving upon his vote total from 2016 and that this “never” happens.
Facts First: Nothing in the 2020 election results was mathematically impossible. Losing the election while winning almost every so-called bellwether county is neither impossible nor a sign that something improper happened; in any given election, any particular county or group of counties can be less aligned with the nation than it had been in previous elections. It is also entirely possible mathematically for a president to legitimately lose a reelection race while earning more total votes than he did when he won his previous race. Trump was the fourth incumbent to have this happen, though the first in more than a century.
Let’s look at his two claims one by one.
The list of ‘bellwethers’ is always changing
For decades, in the 19th century and early 20th century, Maine was seen as a bellwether state – “widely regarded as a political barometer for the nation,” as one 1932 scholarly paper put it.
Then it lost its bellwether status with a sudden thud. In the 1936 election, the Republican presidential candidate, Alf Landon, won Maine but only one other state, Vermont, while getting demolished by President Franklin D. Roosevelt.
There is, clearly, nothing magical or permanent about being considered a bellwether state. Similarly, there is nothing magical or permanent about being considered a bellwether county. At any time, a county can fall out of step with the nation for an endless list of reasons – reasons that have nothing to do with fraud.
David Hopkins, an associate professor of political science at Boston College, said in an email: “Occasionally, a particular county will have a lucky streak of voting for the winner in five or six consecutive elections, but those streaks always end eventually – just like winning streaks in sports don’t go on forever – and don’t reveal anything about the legitimacy of the national outcome.”
Hopkins said, “There is no such thing as a county that can show who won the national election with ’100% predictability.’ There are over 3,000 counties in the US, and every single one of them has sometimes voted for the losing candidate in a presidential election.”
It is true that, in the 2020 election, Trump carried 18 of the 19 counties that had previously gone for the Electoral College winner in every presidential election from 1980 through 2016, as The Wall Street Journal reported in 2020. But that’s an interesting little factoid, not an impossibility or proof of fraud. The website FiveThirtyEight pointed out in 2021 that, in the 2016 election Trump won, opponent Hillary Clinton carried 16 of the 35 counties that had gone for the winner in every election from 1980 through 2012. Those 16 counties having fallen off the bellwether list in 2016 wasn’t an impossibility or proof of fraud, either
Also, “bellwether” is an imprecise term that can be defined in different ways. For example, Washington Post journalist Philip Bump reported last week that, if you define bellwether as a county that was carried by the winner of the country’s popular vote in each presidential election from 1980 through 2016, rather than by the winner of the Electoral College, Biden won all six of the counties that were on that bellwether list as of 2020.
Trump got more votes in 2020 than in 2016. But Biden got more votes than him
It was not mathematically impossible for Trump to get more votes in 2020 than in 2016 but lose in 2020. In fact, it is not even particularly confusing how this happened.
The population kept growing and kept getting more diverse, voter turnout spiked, third-party candidates earned a much lower share of the vote than they did in 2016 – and, critically, Biden improved on the Democrats’ 2016 vote total by even more than Trump improved on his own 2016 vote total.
Trump earned more than 74 million votes in 2020 versus about 63 million in 2016, an improvement of more than 11 million votes. But Biden earned more than 81 million votes in 2020 compared to fewer than 66 million votes for Clinton in 2016 – an improvement of more than 15 million.
The result of Biden’s performance was that he beat Trump 306-232 in the Electoral College.
The end. There is just no valid reason to declare that there is some sort of statistical mystery here, let alone a statistical impossibility.
And contrary to Gibbs’ claim, there is precedent, too.
President Grover Cleveland lost the 1888 election despite earning more than 10% more votes than he did when he won in 1884; President Martin Van Buren lost the 1840 election despite earning more than 45% more votes than he did when he won in 1836; President John Quincy Adams lost the 1828 election despite earning more than 300% more votes than he did when he won in the messy 1824 election in which he was chosen as president by the House of Representatives.
All of this was a long time ago, under very different social and electoral circumstances. But it still disproves Gibbs’ statement that it was “certainly unprecedented in history” for Trump to lose with more votes than he earned four years prior.
In a statement Friday, Gibbs stood by his false claims and said he “could not be more honored” to be “attacked” by CNN. He went on to criticize CNN at length and denounce “the Fake News industry” for supposed bias in favor of Meijer.
Total useless crapola. DC Draino is a Maga jerk. Take that mathematically impossible to court and get sanctioned. !
Recent DJT News
- Trump Media Announces $69.4 Million in Initial Proceeds from Warrant Exercise • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 06/21/2024 09:20:00 PM
- Honeywell Acquires CAES Systems for $1.9 Billion, Sarepta Therapeutics Surges 34%, Gilead Continues Gains • IH Market News • 06/21/2024 12:00:38 PM
- Trump Media Resells Stocks and Warrants; KB Home Exceeds Q2 Expectations, and More News • IH Market News • 06/20/2024 10:55:11 AM
- Trump Media & Technology Group Corp. Announces SEC Effectiveness of Amended Form S-1 • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 06/18/2024 08:30:01 PM
- FDA Panel Supports Eli Lilly’s Donanemab, Rio Tinto Expands Stake in Boyne Smelters, and More News • IH Market News • 06/11/2024 11:11:40 AM
- Trump Media & Technology Group Corp. Files Amended S-1 with the SEC • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 06/10/2024 03:08:45 PM
- Apollo Buys 49% of Intel’s Irish Plant for $11bn, BlackRock and Citadel to Create Texas Exchange, and More News • IH Market News • 06/05/2024 11:41:36 AM
- DJT Stock Falls 6% Post-Trump Conviction; UBS Restructures Senior Management for CEO Succession and More News • IH Market News • 05/31/2024 11:54:10 AM
- Trump Media Shares Drop Following Donald Trump Conviction • IH Market News • 05/31/2024 09:19:39 AM
- CalPERS to Oppose Exxon Mobil Directors; Microsoft Unveils Copilot+ PCs with AI Focus, and More News • IH Market News • 05/21/2024 11:18:35 AM
- TMTG Reports First Quarter 2024 Results • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 05/20/2024 08:05:00 PM
- Chubb Stock Soars 9% with Berkshire Acquisition, AST SpaceMobile jumps 37% on AT&T deal, and More News • IH Market News • 05/16/2024 11:27:07 AM
- Tesla’s April Sales Down 18% in China, Amazon’s Multi-Billion Dollar Cloud Expansion in Singapore, and More News • IH Market News • 05/07/2024 11:44:00 AM
- Trump Media Announces Appointment of Semple, Marchal & Cooper, LLP as Auditor • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 05/06/2024 08:15:10 PM
- Trump Media Provides Additional Information to DJT Investors Regarding Recalling Shares • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 04/29/2024 10:00:00 AM
- Coca-Cola and Microsoft Sign Billion-Dollar Agreement, Apple Event Set for May 7, and More News • IH Market News • 04/24/2024 11:28:02 AM
- Trump Media Provides Additional Information To DJT Investors Regarding Short Selling • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 04/23/2024 10:00:44 AM
- Paramount’s Shares Surge Following Sony and Apollo’s Joint Bid; ISS Backs Berkshire Hathaway Director Re-election, and More • IH Market News • 04/19/2024 11:31:22 AM
- Apple to Invest $250 Million in Singapore Expansion, Oracle Commits $8 Billion to Japan Infrastructure, and More News • IH Market News • 04/18/2024 11:11:52 AM
- United Shares Surge 5.3% in Q1 2024 Earnings Beat; Take-Two Cuts 5% of Workforce, and More News • IH Market News • 04/17/2024 10:57:39 AM
- Truth Social to Launch Streaming Platform • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 04/16/2024 11:24:00 AM
- Ericsson Soars with 66% Net Profit Growth; Live Nation Under Antitrust Scrutiny in US, and More News • IH Market News • 04/16/2024 11:18:19 AM
- Trump Media & Technology Group Files S-1 Resale Registration Statement • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 04/15/2024 01:17:42 PM
- Tesla Resolves Autopilot Lawsuit, JPMorgan Unveils Potential CEO Successors, and More • IH Market News • 04/09/2024 10:39:30 AM
- Apple Terminates 614 Employees, Disney Unveils June Crackdown on Password Sharing, and More Updates • IH Market News • 04/05/2024 11:38:57 AM
Last Shot Hydration Drink Announced as Official Sponsor of Red River Athletic Conference • EQLB • Jun 20, 2024 2:38 PM
ATWEC Announces Major Acquisition and Lays Out Strategic Growth Plans • ATWT • Jun 20, 2024 7:09 AM
North Bay Resources Announces Composite Assays of 0.53 and 0.44 Troy Ounces per Ton Gold in Trenches B + C at Fran Gold, British Columbia • NBRI • Jun 18, 2024 9:18 AM
VAYK Assembling New Management Team for $64 Billion Domestic Market • VAYK • Jun 18, 2024 9:00 AM
Fifty 1 Labs, Inc Announces Acquisition of Drago Knives, LLC • CAFI • Jun 18, 2024 8:45 AM
Hydromer Announces Attainment of ISO 13485 Certification • HYDI • Jun 17, 2024 9:22 AM