![](https://investorshub.advfn.com/uicon/33935.png?cb=1540179761)
Friday, December 01, 2023 8:55:00 PM
Judge scolds SEC for apparent deception in crypto case, threatens to sanction agency.
The SEC is suing crypto firm DEBT Box for allegedly defrauding investors out of nearly $50 million.
BY
LEO SCHWARTZ
AND
JEFF JOHN ROBERTS
December 01, 2023 4:47 PM EST
SEC Chair Gary Gensler has engaged in an aggressive campaign of enforcement actions against crypto firms. Tom Williams—Getty Images
A federal judge has rebuked the Securities and Exchange Commission over its treatment of a crypto firm, expressing concern the agency had made “materially false and misleading representations” in order to freeze millions of dollars in assets belonging to the project.
The case, filed in Utah federal court, concerns a firm called Digital Licensing Inc., or DEBT Box. In its complaint, filed this summer, the SEC alleged the project had defrauded investors out of nearly $50 million by selling unregistered securities called “node licenses.”
As part of the initial process, the SEC successfully obtained a temporary restraining order and asset seizure through a so-called ex parte application—meaning the crypto firm was not informed of the proceedings and was not able to challenge them in court at the time.
These types of one-sided proceedings are uncommon and typically take place when a government agency fears that notifying the defendant will result in their destroying evidence or whisking assets overseas. Meanwhile, a temporary restraining order requires a party to show a high likelihood of “irreparable harm”—a high bar to clear.
?
In his Thursday order, U.S. District Judge Robert Shelby explained he had agreed to grant the SEC’s request because the agency’s lawyer, Michael Welsh, had said the crypto company was actively closing bank accounts—including 33 in the last 48 hours—as part of a bid to move the firm to Abu Dhabi and beyond the reach of U.S. regulators.
This turned out to be untrue, however. In his order, Shelby argued that some of the SEC’s arguments were “entirely without merit and misstate the record.” He wrote that subsequent legal proceedings revealed that no bank accounts had been closed during the 48-hour window and that the company had already transferred much of its operations months before. He also found that it was banks, not the company, that had closed certain accounts and that one alleged overseas transfer of $720,000 the SEC had used to justify the ex parte seizure had actually been a domestic transfer.
Shelby wrote that he was “troubled” by the SEC attorney’s misrepresentation of the account closures because there was another attorney on-screen, as well as two investigative staffers off-screen, who did not clarify or correct the attorney’s statement, nor was it addressed in later filings.
The judge also argued that the SEC has accused the crypto company of blocking investigators from viewing its social media sites, saying the agency had not shown any evidence to suggest the firm had even known about any investigation.
Given all this, Shelby concluded that the SEC had possibly deceived the court in its description of the facts used to justify the earlier orders.
“The court is concerned the Commission made materially false and misleading representations that violated Rule 11(b) and undermined the integrity of the proceedings,” wrote Shelby, citing a federal court rule that says written facts submitted to a judge must be supported by evidence.
SEC faces sanctions
The document issued by Shelby came in the form of a “show cause order”—a request that in this case demands the SEC provide reasons why the Utah court should not punish the agency for its behavior. While such orders are not uncommon, they are typically directed at private parties and very rarely at government agencies.
The order on Thursday concludes with a list of questions asking the SEC to respond to specific examples of apparent falsehoods, including the agency’s claims made about the closed bank accounts and the social media blocking.
While the tone of Shelby’s order is restrained, the judge appears to have been angered by the fact that the SEC submitted the apparent misstatements in an ex parte context and for a temporary restraining order—legal processes that courts are mostly reluctant to grant as they deprive defendants of due process. In his filing, the judge states that he is “concerned” the SEC “undermined the integrity of the proceedings.”
The federal rule cited by Shelby doesn’t provide specific sanctions for given violations but rather proposes a range of measures from a financial penalty to a directive that “suffices to deter repetition of the conduct.”
End Of Line.
Recent XRPUSD News
- Crypto Analyst Predicts XRP Price To Hit $1.03 Soon, Warns Of Initial Dip • NEWSBTC • 07/18/2024 04:30:35 PM
- XRP Lawsuit: Ripple CEO Expects Resolution with SEC “Very Soon” • ZyCrypto • 07/18/2024 01:08:44 PM
- XRP Price Plummets To $0.5724, Can Bulls Maintain Support? • NEWSBTC • 07/18/2024 12:00:22 PM
- XRP Surges 39% As Sharks & Whales Push Supply Share Past 85% • NEWSBTC • 07/18/2024 05:00:51 AM
- XRP Price Regains $0.60: Key Levels to Watch Moving Forward • NEWSBTC • 07/18/2024 04:08:02 AM
- XRP Skyrockets 40% As Speculation Of Ripple-SEC Settlement Gains Momentum • NEWSBTC • 07/17/2024 08:57:26 PM
- Price analysis 7/17: BTC, ETH, BNB, SOL, XRP, DOGE, TON, ADA, AVAX, SHIB • Cointelegraph • 07/17/2024 08:30:00 PM
- Silicon Valley Using Trump For A Bitcoin Pump Play? Mark Cuban Weighs In • NEWSBTC • 07/17/2024 07:47:23 PM
- Bitcoin ETFs Surge, Grayscale Launches AI Fund, XRP Soars 40% in One Week • IH Market News • 07/17/2024 07:10:01 PM
- Ripple Withdraws Investments in Bitstamp, MoneyGram and Tranglo, According to Crunchbase • The Daily Hodl • 07/17/2024 06:45:35 PM
- Prophet Who Accurately Predicted Trump’s Assassination Attempt Foresees XRP’s Monstrous Breakout To $10,000 • ZyCrypto • 07/17/2024 05:21:28 PM
- Pro-XRP Lawyer Debunks Ripple-SEC Settlement Rumor For Tomorrow • NEWSBTC • 07/17/2024 05:00:05 PM
- Executives From Coinbase, Ripple and Another Crypto Firm Now Making Their Case to Republican Power Brokers: Report • The Daily Hodl • 07/17/2024 04:55:47 PM
- XRP Whales Are On The Move Again – Here’s What They’re Doing This Time • NEWSBTC • 07/17/2024 02:00:35 PM
- Why is XRP price up today? • Cointelegraph • 07/17/2024 11:06:49 AM
- Expert Foresees XRP Soaring To $250: Technical Analysis Explained • NEWSBTC • 07/17/2024 08:30:08 AM
- XRP Price Grinds Higher: Is A Break Above $0.60 Imminent? • NEWSBTC • 07/17/2024 04:08:53 AM
- Crypto Analyst Predicts Multiple God Candles For XRP, How High Can It Go? • NEWSBTC • 07/17/2024 01:30:38 AM
- XRP & Litecoin See Social Media FOMO: Bad Sign For Prices? • NEWSBTC • 07/17/2024 12:00:57 AM
- Ripple backs Deaton with $1M donation in senate race against Warren • Cointelegraph • 07/16/2024 09:10:06 PM
- Ripple Lawsuit: Pundit Predicts Historic 60,000% Surge For XRP Price as Settlement Looms • ZyCrypto • 07/16/2024 09:09:35 PM
- Binance’s Nigerian Tax Evasion Ruling Set for October After Not Guilty Plea: Report • The Daily Hodl • 07/16/2024 04:55:49 PM
- XRP Price Surges Ahead: Bullish Trends Signal Promising Price Upswing! • NEWSBTC • 07/16/2024 04:58:07 AM
- Bitcoin Surpasses $63K, Miners Accumulate, Exchanges Limit Brokerage Fee Discounts • IH Market News • 07/15/2024 07:32:17 PM
- Ripple’s XRP Ready To Blast Off Higher As SEC’s Upcoming Private Meeting Signals Potential Resolution This Thursday • ZyCrypto • 07/15/2024 06:18:44 PM
FEATURED North Bay Resources Acquires Mt. Vernon Gold Mine, Sierra County, California, with Assays up to 4.8 oz. Au per Ton • Jul 18, 2024 9:00 AM
FEATURED Nightfood Holdings Signs Letter of Intent for All-Stock Acquisition of CarryOutSupplies.com • Jul 17, 2024 1:00 PM
VAYK Expects Revenue from First Airbnb Property Starting from August • VAYK • Jul 18, 2024 9:00 AM
Kona Gold Beverages Reaches Out to Largest Debt Holder for Debt Purchase Negotiation • KGKG • Jul 17, 2024 9:00 AM
Avant Technologies Welcomes Back Former CEO with Eye Toward Future Growth and Expansion • AVAI • Jul 17, 2024 8:00 AM
HealthLynked Expands Telemedicine Nationwide • HLYK • Jul 17, 2024 8:00 AM