Followers | 686 |
Posts | 142801 |
Boards Moderated | 35 |
Alias Born | 03/10/2004 |
![](https://investorshub.advfn.com/uicon/35728.png?cb=1539773763)
Wednesday, July 13, 2022 4:01:46 PM
By: Vince Martin | July 13, 2022
• An activist short report on Nio seems to miss the mark
• Perhaps the most aggressive accusation appears to have been disproven
• But Nio is responding as if there is some truth to the story; investors should keep that in mind
Late last month, activist short seller Grizzly Research took aim at Chinese electric vehicle manufacturer Nio (NYSE:NIO). Some investors no doubt shrugged off the report without even reading it.
![](http://d1-invdn-com.investing.com/content/pice6e38a63d3aa568b1e07807e6b94d27c.png)
NIO Weekly Chart.
Source: Investing.com
Some of those investors might simply dislike short sellers. The rise of meme stocks, like AMC Entertainment (NYSE:AMC) and GameStop (NYSE:GME), has engendered deep disdain for those traders making bearish bets. Some might see a conflict of interest for Grizzly, which disclosed a short position in NIO stock ahead of the release of its report.
Neither is a reason to dismiss the report out of hand, however. Short selling, and activist short selling in particular, provide important checks on market exuberance. Those checks offer value to the rest of the market — but can't be incentivized without creating some value for the short seller.
Indeed, no one should know this better than investors in a Chinese electric vehicle stock. Well-known firm Muddy Waters Research made its name correctly identifying fraud in that country. That same firm in early 2020 passed along an anonymous report that correctly spotted financial regularities at Luckin Coffee (OTC:LKNCY).
Activist sellers have targeted the EV space as well. Perhaps the most impactful of those campaigns was the report from Hindenburg Research on Nikola (NASDAQ:NKLA). Hindenburg's research led not only to a plunging NKLA stock price but federal charges against its founder.
To be clear, that history doesn't mean Grizzly's own report is correct. Indeed, the firm appears to have made at least one significant mistake. But Nio itself seems to be taking the allegations seriously. Investors should as well.
The Grizzly Research Allegations
Grizzly's report on NIO can be described as having three core pillars.
The first is an argument that Nio is using a third party to inflate its revenue. Nio has developed a so-called “BaaS” (battery-as-a-service) program that allows vehicle purchasers to subscribe to a battery swap program in lieu of purchasing a battery upfront. The BaaS program, however, is run by a separate company, Wuhan Weineng Battery Asset Co., of which Nio owns 19.8%.
That setup allows Nio to book the revenues from the battery subscriptions it sells upfront, instead of over a period of years. To be clear, this is not illegal, as even Grizzly notes. In fact, this revenue treatment is required under accounting rules. But the effect is to inflate Nio's current revenue — and, more importantly, its profits.
Grizzly alleges that Nio has gone even further, however. It highlights a document from Wuhan Weineng, noting that as of Sept. 30, 2021, the company was servicing 19,000 subscribers. Yet, Wuhan Weineng at the same point had purchased more than 40,000 batteries from Nio.
Grizzly sees no need for these extra sales — and no signs of those batteries actually being stored anywhere. And so the firm concludes that Nio is allegedly overshipping batteries that it simply keeps at its service centers, further boosting revenue and earnings.
Finally, Grizzly raises some concerns about governance. It points to the installation of Nio executives at the head of Wuhan Weineng as disproving Nio's claims that it doesn't control that company. Grizzly notes the ties of Nio chairman Bin Li to individuals and entities involved in the Luckin fraud. And the firm claims that Li pledged shares ostensibly owned by Nio users to back loans, and that Li may well have routed 50 million RMB (roughly $7.4 million) to his personal account through Nio.
Is Grizzly Right?
Nio's initial response was to claim that “the report was without merit.” For the most part, the market seems to have agreed. NIO stock did drop about 3% on the day the report was released — but the entire market was down, with the less-volatile S&P 500 index declining 2%.
And, indeed, there appears to be a key error on perhaps the most inflammatory claim. The 19,000 subscriber figure was derived by a prospectus from Wuhan Weineng for an asset-backed financing. But as a number of users on Twitter pointed out, that prospectus doesn't cover all of the BaaS users — only a subset. Grizzly's claim here appears to fall completely flat.
As far as the argument that revenue and earnings are being inflated, there is some truth to it. But it's worth noting that accounting treatments typically depress the reported profits of SaaS companies. Costs are booked upfront; revenue is recognized over time. For this reason, in SaaS (software-as-a-service) businesses, investors often focus more on cash flow (where upfront payments are booked 100%) and/or pay close attention to deferred revenue balances.
The existence of Wuhan Weineng does perhaps suggests that Nio's results are better than they would be otherwise — but it does not imply that those results are distorted. Indeed, in the hypothetical scenario where Wuhan Weineng didn't exist, investors to some extent would treat Nio's BaaS revenue the same way they do SaaS, and make their own adjustments in valuing the business.
Reason For Concern?
Overall, the case made by Grizzly doesn't quite land. But that doesn't mean investors can or should simply dismiss the report out of hand.
There are governance concerns here. The pledging of Nio shares, if true, at best would be a significant violation of trust.
Grizzly notes that Chinese government entities — who rescued Nio when the company was at legitimate risk of bankruptcy in late 2019 — continue to redeem shares at a rapid clip. Nio still has obligations on that front that could total as much as $6.7 billion — and only $8.2 billion in cash on hand ahead of a planned global expansion. The firm is correct in noting that further redemptions could cause Nio to need to raise additional capital — which likely would require equity issuance and thus shareholder dilution.
The risks aren't as explosive as Grizzly's broader tone would suggest. But this still is a company with a market capitalization just shy of $35 billion — and no profitability in immediate sight. (Wall Street consensus projects a modest loss in 2023.) It's also a company that this week said it would form an independent committee of directors to probe the allegations made by Grizzly.
Perhaps that response is intended to mollify the market, and remove any semblance of doubt raised by the short report. But it's worth noting that Nio said its committee would be advised by “a well-regarded forensic accounting firm.”
That kind of firm isn't necessarily one required to respond to an error-riddled report with no basis in fact. It suggests that Nio's board at least wonders if there might be something to at least some of the allegations made here. Given the history of the space, and the still-stretched valuation, that's a risk investors, at the least, need to be aware of.
Read Full Story »»»
![](http://studentaid.gov/universal-navigation/assets/us_flag_small.png)
Information posted to this board is not meant to suggest any specific action, but to point out the technical signs that can help our readers make their own specific decisions. Caveat emptor!
• DiscoverGold
Recent NIO News
- Form S-8 - Securities to be offered to employees in employee benefit plans • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 07/09/2024 10:24:34 AM
- NIO Inc. Announces Management Change • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 07/05/2024 09:30:10 AM
- NIO Inc. Provides June and Second Quarter 2024 Delivery Update • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 07/01/2024 09:30:03 AM
- Cheche Group Announces Partnership with NIO Insurance Broker • PR Newswire (US) • 06/20/2024 11:30:00 AM
- GME Volatile as Roaring Kitty Goes Live Today, Meta Unveils AI for WhatsApp Ads, and More • IH Market News • 06/07/2024 12:09:15 PM
- US Index Futures Mixed; Oil Prices Rise • IH Market News • 06/06/2024 11:29:43 AM
- NIO Inc. Reports Unaudited First Quarter 2024 Financial Results • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 06/06/2024 10:10:50 AM
- Apollo Buys 49% of Intel’s Irish Plant for $11bn, BlackRock and Citadel to Create Texas Exchange, and More News • IH Market News • 06/05/2024 11:41:36 AM
- NIO Inc. Provides May 2024 Delivery Update • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 06/01/2024 09:30:59 AM
- Form 6-K - Report of foreign issuer [Rules 13a-16 and 15d-16] • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 05/24/2024 10:14:54 AM
- NIO to Hold Annual General Meeting on June 25, 2024 • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 05/24/2024 09:30:44 AM
- Form 6-K - Report of foreign issuer [Rules 13a-16 and 15d-16] • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 05/22/2024 10:06:28 AM
- NIO Inc. to Report Unaudited First Quarter 2024 Financial Results on Thursday, June 6, 2024 • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 05/22/2024 09:30:11 AM
- Form 424B3 - Prospectus [Rule 424(b)(3)] • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 05/21/2024 08:28:12 PM
- Form F-3ASR - Automatic shelf registration statement of securities of well-known seasoned issuers • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 05/21/2024 08:02:10 PM
- Chubb Stock Soars 9% with Berkshire Acquisition, AST SpaceMobile jumps 37% on AT&T deal, and More News • IH Market News • 05/16/2024 11:27:07 AM
- Form 6-K - Report of foreign issuer [Rules 13a-16 and 15d-16] • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 05/16/2024 10:07:01 AM
- Arm Sets 2025 Target for AI Chip Development, Amazon and Microsoft Commit Billions to French Investments, and More • IH Market News • 05/13/2024 11:16:03 AM
- Tesla’s April Sales Down 18% in China, Amazon’s Multi-Billion Dollar Cloud Expansion in Singapore, and More News • IH Market News • 05/07/2024 11:44:00 AM
- NIO Inc. Provides April 2024 Delivery Update • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 05/01/2024 09:30:24 AM
- Samsung Surpasses Apple in Q1 Smartphone Market; Salesforce in Talks to Acquire Informatica, and More News • IH Market News • 04/15/2024 11:06:48 AM
- NIO Inc. Files Its 2023 Annual Report on Form 20-F • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 04/09/2024 10:11:21 AM
- NIO Inc. Provides March and First Quarter 2024 Delivery Update • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 04/01/2024 09:30:26 AM
- NIO Inc. Prudently Adjusts First Quarter 2024 Delivery Outlook • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 03/27/2024 09:30:20 AM
- Fisker’s Shares Take a Hit Amid Speculation of Bankruptcy, Altria Divests from AB InBev to Fund Stock Repurchase Initiative • IH Market News • 03/14/2024 11:39:32 AM
Greenlite Ventures Completes Agreement with No Limit Technology • GRNL • Jul 19, 2024 10:00 AM
VAYK Expects Revenue from First Airbnb Property Starting from August • VAYK • Jul 18, 2024 9:00 AM
North Bay Resources Acquires Mt. Vernon Gold Mine, Sierra County, California, with Assays up to 4.8 oz. Au per Ton • NBRI • Jul 18, 2024 9:00 AM
Nightfood Holdings Signs Letter of Intent for All-Stock Acquisition of CarryOutSupplies.com • NGTF • Jul 17, 2024 1:00 PM
Kona Gold Beverages Reaches Out to Largest Debt Holder for Debt Purchase Negotiation • KGKG • Jul 17, 2024 9:00 AM
Avant Technologies Welcomes Back Former CEO with Eye Toward Future Growth and Expansion • AVAI • Jul 17, 2024 8:00 AM