Thursday, February 17, 2022 7:39:16 AM
Justice Department Targets ‘Spoofing’ and ‘Scalping’ in Short-Seller Investigation
Muddy Waters’s Carson Block served with a search warrant in the probe of illegal trading tactics
Carson Block, the fiery short-seller behind Muddy Waters, was served with a search warrant by an FBI agent in October, people familiar with the matter said.
Federal prosecutors are investigating whether short-sellers conspired to drive down stock prices by sharing damaging research reports ahead of time and engaging in illegal trading tactics, people familiar with the matter said.
The U.S. Justice Department has seized hardware, trading records and private communications in an effort to prove a wide-ranging conspiracy among investors who bet against corporate shares, the people said. One tactic under investigation is “spoofing,” an illegal ploy that involves flooding the market with fake orders in an effort to push a stock price up or down, they said. Another is “scalping,” where activist short-sellers cash out their positions without disclosing it.
Carson Block, the fiery short-seller behind Muddy Waters, was served with a search warrant by an FBI agent in October, said people familiar with the matter, one of whom added that the warrant extended to Mr. Block’s phones. Federal agents took computers belonging to Andrew Left, another prominent short-seller, according to Bloomberg News, which previously reported the existence of an investigation.
Never the most popular camp on Wall Street, short-sellers have had an especially bruising few years. Soaring stock markets, even through the pandemic, undercut their bearish bets. They were cast as villains last year by the meme-stock crowd, who delighted in forcing them into steep losses. Some have thrown in the towel altogether.
Still, they can play a crucial role in uncovering corporate frauds. One short-seller helped turn up the heat on Enron. Others were early to sound the alarm on the 2008 financial crisis and more recent scandals including at Wirecard AG . Now they may have to defend themselves against a federal investigation, which is being led in part by the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Los Angeles, an office known for prosecuting organized crime rings.
Media reports on the investigation have compelled prominent short-sellers such as Andrew Left to defend their actions.
Photo: brendan mcdermid/Reuters
Spoofing is essentially high-speed bluffing, in which one trader dupes others into transacting at artificially high or low prices. A spoofer, for example, might offer to sell a big block of shares at $10 when the last sale was at $10.03. After other sellers rush to match the lower price, the spoofer quickly pivots, canceling his sell order and instead buying at the $10 price he generated with the fake bid. Repeated enough times, spoofing can produce big profits.
The tactic was outlawed in 2010. In 2016 a New Jersey commodities trader was sentenced to three years in prison, the government’s first criminal spoofing case and the beginning of a crackdown. The same year, the trader who was blamed for the 2010 “flash crash,” when the stock market lost and quickly regained almost $1 trillion in value, pleaded guilty to spoofing and was sentenced to a year’s house arrest. By 2020, the Justice Department had charged 20 people with spoofing-related crimes and collected more than $1 billion in fines from banks and other financial institutions.
Media reports on the current investigation have compelled prominent short-sellers such as Messrs. Block and Left to defend their actions and highlight their success in uncovering corporate frauds. The investors and their lawyers have said they are confused by the Justice Department’s interest in their investing tactics and suspect the government has seized on academic research they believe has unfairly portrayed activist investors as bad actors who conspire to manipulate markets.
Columbia Law School professor Joshua Mitts, who published a 2020 academic paper entitled “Short and Distort” that was critical of short-selling tactics, has been advising the Justice Department in its investigation, people familiar with the matter said. Mr. Mitts has in the past also served as an expert for companies and executives, including Farmland Partners Inc. and Banc of California’s former CEO, that have sued short-sellers, alleging they promoted false or misleading research.
Analyses performed by Mr. Mitts on those companies—prepared in private litigation, not for the Justice Department investigation—show that in the moments around the release of a short-seller report, heavy volumes of sell orders are sent to exchanges and then canceled within fractions of a second, according to documents reviewed by The Wall Street Journal. That behavior, Mr. Mitts argues in the documents, is a telltale sign of spoofing.
“We are happy that the Justice Department is looking into this, as we have said for a long time our shareholders were the victims of an orchestrated ‘short-and-distort’ attack,” said Paul Pittman, chief executive of Farmland, whose shares fell 39% the day a Texas short-seller accused the company of financial misdeeds in 2018.
Farmland sued both an investment-research firm and a hedge fund, alleging they publicized a false and misleading report. The researcher later issued a public apology, a rare win for a company targeted in such a campaign.
Short sellers argue that, at least once, Mr. Mitts’s theories on spoofing didn’t hold up in court. In 2020, a U.K. High Court judge dismissed his findings that short-sellers had relied on spoofing to drive down the stock price of Burford Capital Ltd. , a litigation-finance firm.
It was Mr. Block’s Muddy Waters whose research report on Burford had triggered a 50% drop in the stock.
—Julie Steinberg contributed to this article.
Recent AMC News
- Mike Rowe Presents SOMETHING TO STAND FOR Coming to Theaters Nationwide - Beginning June 27 • PR Newswire (US) • 05/23/2024 01:00:00 PM
- Summer Movie Camp Returns to AMC Theatres® With Popular Family Titles at Just $3 Plus Tax Per Ticket • Business Wire • 05/23/2024 10:45:00 AM
- Chubb Stock Soars 9% with Berkshire Acquisition, AST SpaceMobile jumps 37% on AT&T deal, and More News • IH Market News • 05/16/2024 11:27:07 AM
- Nike Cuts Jobs at Converse, Ilya Sutskever Departs from OpenAI, WBD Increases Buyback Offer, and More News • IH Market News • 05/15/2024 11:49:06 AM
- Meme Stock GameStop Rallies After Roaring Kitty Post • IH Market News • 05/14/2024 12:31:22 PM
- Walmart Corporate Job Cuts and Office Centralization, GameStop and AMC Surge, and More News • IH Market News • 05/14/2024 11:26:02 AM
- Airbnb Stocks Drop 8% Amid Bleak Outlook; Bumble Surges 14% on Global Download Rise, and More in Earnings • IH Market News • 05/09/2024 11:56:30 AM
- AMC Entertainment Holdings, Inc. Reports First Quarter 2024 Results • Business Wire • 05/08/2024 08:22:00 PM
- U.S. Futures Slightly Dip Amid Corporate Earnings and Quiet Economic Calendar, Oil Prices Fall • IH Market News • 05/08/2024 12:29:17 PM
- Bottles of the Year Program from Amcor Showcases the Best New Designs in Responsible Packaging • Business Wire • 05/07/2024 03:00:00 PM
- Alphabet CEO’s Billion-Dollar Wealth, Microsoft’s $1.7B Indonesia Investment, and More News • IH Market News • 04/30/2024 11:58:40 AM
- AMC Entertainment Holdings, Inc. Previews First Quarter 2024 Preliminary Results and Announces First Quarter 2024 Earnings Webcast • Business Wire • 04/26/2024 08:15:00 PM
- United Shares Surge 5.3% in Q1 2024 Earnings Beat; Take-Two Cuts 5% of Workforce, and More News • IH Market News • 04/17/2024 10:57:39 AM
- Walgreens Slashes Annual Profit Forecast; MillerKnoll Nosedives 17% on Bleak 4Q Outlook, and Latest News • IH Market News • 03/28/2024 01:48:04 PM
- Amcor announces CEO transition and reaffirms fiscal 2024 outlook • PR Newswire (US) • 03/19/2024 08:15:00 PM
- Zoom Rooms at AMC Is Now Live at Several AMC Locations Across the Country as AMC Theatres® and Zoom Redefine Interactive Business Meetings and Hybrid Events • Business Wire • 03/14/2024 10:45:00 AM
- AMC Entertainment Holdings, Inc. Provides Settlement Notice • Business Wire • 03/12/2024 08:30:00 PM
- AMC Significantly Expands the Availability of its Popular Grocery Store Popcorn Through the Addition of Publix and Kroger Stores, and Amazon.com • Business Wire • 03/11/2024 05:09:00 PM
- AMC Entertainment Holdings, Inc. Board of Directors Elects Sonia Jain to Serve as a Director of the Company, Effective March 1, 2024 • Business Wire • 03/01/2024 11:45:00 AM
- Snowflake Stock Plummets 20.3% After CEO Transition; C3.ai, Okta, and Duolingo Surge Post-Strong Quarterly Reports, and More • IH Market News • 02/29/2024 11:09:45 AM
- AMC Entertainment Holdings, Inc. Reports Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2023 Results • Business Wire • 02/28/2024 09:15:00 PM
- AMC Entertainment Holdings, Inc. to Announce Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2023 Results and Host Earnings Webcast • Business Wire • 02/05/2024 09:15:00 PM
- KISS THE FUTURE – The Critically Acclaimed Documentary About a Creative Community Amid the Siege of Sarajevo, the Resilience of Its People Through Art and Music and the Tale of a Post-war Concert by U2 – to Receive a Theatrical Run Exclusively at AMC • Business Wire • 01/31/2024 07:00:00 PM
- "Forty-Seven Days With Jesus", Starring The Chosen's Yoshi Barrigas & Catherine Lidstone, Coming To Over 800 Theaters In A Special Three-Day Fathom Event • PR Newswire (US) • 01/30/2024 09:45:00 PM
- This Friday Is National Popcorn Day, and AMC Theatres® Is Celebrating With Unlimited Popcorn Refill Deals and Unique Popcorn-Themed Merch Available in Theatres and Online • Business Wire • 01/17/2024 01:00:00 PM
Avant Technologies Engages Wired4Tech to Evaluate the Performance of Next Generation AI Server Technology • AVAI • May 23, 2024 8:00 AM
Branded Legacy, Inc. Unveils Collaboration with Celebrity Tattoo Artist Kat Tat for New Tattoo Aftercare Product • BLEG • May 22, 2024 8:30 AM
"Defo's Morning Briefing" Set to Debut for "GreenliteTV" • GRNL • May 21, 2024 2:28 PM
North Bay Resources Announces 50/50 JV at Fran Gold Project, British Columbia; Initiates NI 43-101 Resources Estimate and Bulk Sample • NBRI • May 21, 2024 9:07 AM
Greenlite Ventures Inks Deal to Acquire No Limit Technology • GRNL • May 17, 2024 3:00 PM
Music Licensing, Inc. (OTC: SONG) Subsidiary Pro Music Rights Secures Final Judgment of $114,081.30 USD, Demonstrating Strength of Licensing Agreements • SONGD • May 17, 2024 11:00 AM