Probably each contract arbitration agreement is different. In these situations both parties receive a list of individuals to arbitrate 1 through 5, 1 through 10 however many that may be on the list. It is the responsibility of that person to go through each resume and rank 1 through 10 to be your “favorite” Same with the other side. The highest favorite from both parties is then chosen weather that favorite is 1 3 4 or 6.