$LYFT Lyft drivers question company's future as a public company
Sara O'Brien byline
By Sara Ashley O'Brien, CNN Business
Updated 12:33 PM ET, Fri March 29, 2019
Get ready for an IPO onslaught
Pause
MuteMute
Current Time 0:42
/
Duration Time 2:44
Fullscreen
CUPERTINO, CA - MARCH 25: Ann Thai, senior product marketing manager of the App Store at Apple Inc., speaks during a company product launch event at the Steve Jobs Theater at Apple Park on March 25, 2019 in Cupertino, California. Apple announced the launch of it's new video streaming service, unveiled a premium subscription tier to its News app, and announced it would release its own credit card, called Apple Card. (Photo by Michael Short/Getty Images)
Apple launches game subscription service
Video gaming recognized as a high school sport
This controversial app tracks nearby danger in real time
See the Galaxy Fold, Samsung's new foldable phone
Présentation du robot-voiturier à l'aéroport de Lyon Saint Exupéry par la compagnie Stanley Robotics. Enlévement de la voiture avant de la garer sur une place de parking.
This robot named Stan can park your car at the airport
lg display tv oled portable zw gr orig_00000819.jpg
LG says these are the TVs of the future
Tyler 'Ninja' Blevins streams himself playing the popular video game Fortnite. Blevins is considered one of the most popular video gamers in the world making over $500,000 per month playing the game.
Here's how he makes $500,000 per month playing video games
Here's why 5G is the future
NOW PLAYING
Get ready for an IPO onslaught
NEW YORK, NY - AUGUST 8: After dropping off passengers at a Broadway play, Johan Nijman, a for-hire driver who runs his own service and also drives for Uber on the side, drives through the West Side of Manhattan on Wednesday evening, August 8, 2018 in New York City. On Wednesday, New York City became the first American city to halt new vehicles for ride-hail services. The legislation passed by the New York City Council will cap the number of for-hire vehicles for one year while the city studies the industry. The move marks a setback for Uber in its largest U.S. market. Nijman, a member of the Independent Drivers Guild who has been driving in various capacities since 1991, says the temporary vehicle cap is a good start but he would like to see the city do more to deal with the over-saturation of vehicles and new drivers. (Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images)
Uber files to go public
A Wing drone in flight in Australia.
Google's Wing launches drone delivery in Australia
Nintendo announces 'Mario' and 'Zelda' in virtual reality
20190403-snapchat-games-main
See Snapchat's new social games
How influencers keep their #ads and their audiences
Will memes be illegal? EU's copyright overhaul, explained
Here's how Lyft became the 'friendly' rideshare app
CUPERTINO, CA - MARCH 25: Ann Thai, senior product marketing manager of the App Store at Apple Inc., speaks during a company product launch event at the Steve Jobs Theater at Apple Park on March 25, 2019 in Cupertino, California. Apple announced the launch of it's new video streaming service, unveiled a premium subscription tier to its News app, and announced it would release its own credit card, called Apple Card. (Photo by Michael Short/Getty Images)
Apple launches game subscription service
Video gaming recognized as a high school sport
This controversial app tracks nearby danger in real time
See the Galaxy Fold, Samsung's new foldable phone
Présentation du robot-voiturier à l'aéroport de Lyon Saint Exupéry par la compagnie Stanley Robotics. Enlévement de la voiture avant de la garer sur une place de parking.
This robot named Stan can park your car at the airport
lg display tv oled portable zw gr orig_00000819.jpg
LG says these are the TVs of the future
Tyler 'Ninja' Blevins streams himself playing the popular video game Fortnite. Blevins is considered one of the most popular video gamers in the world making over $500,000 per month playing the game.
Here's how he makes $500,000 per month playing video games
Here's why 5G is the future
Get ready for an IPO onslaught
NEW YORK, NY - AUGUST 8: After dropping off passengers at a Broadway play, Johan Nijman, a for-hire driver who runs his own service and also drives for Uber on the side, drives through the West Side of Manhattan on Wednesday evening, August 8, 2018 in New York City. On Wednesday, New York City became the first American city to halt new vehicles for ride-hail services. The legislation passed by the New York City Council will cap the number of for-hire vehicles for one year while the city studies the industry. The move marks a setback for Uber in its largest U.S. market. Nijman, a member of the Independent Drivers Guild who has been driving in various capacities since 1991, says the temporary vehicle cap is a good start but he would like to see the city do more to deal with the over-saturation of vehicles and new drivers. (Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images)
Uber files to go public
A Wing drone in flight in Australia.
Google's Wing launches drone delivery in Australia
Nintendo announces 'Mario' and 'Zelda' in virtual reality
20190403-snapchat-games-main
See Snapchat's new social games
How influencers keep their #ads and their audiences
Will memes be illegal? EU's copyright overhaul, explained
Here's how Lyft became the 'friendly' rideshare app
New York (CNN)As Lyft becomes a public company, there's one group of people that faces an uncertain future: its drivers.
Lyft, like Uber, built its business on the backs of drivers. Just this week, as Lyft was on its IPO roadshow, drivers for both Lyft and Uber organized a strike in Los Angeles over recent pay cuts. At the same time, the company is fighting the implementation of a first-of-its-kind minimum wage law in New York City -- and the debate over the classification of on-demand workers as independent contractors, and what that entitles drivers to, remains a heated issue.
But what happens to drivers and their concerns once the companies start feeling pressures from Wall Street to make money? Drivers and analysts tell CNN Business they aren't so sure things will improve -- although the companies would be smart to try.
Tim Krueger, who drives for Lyft in Grand Rapids, Michigan, said he believes the company views some of its drivers as "screaming people" to put up with until it can replace them with self-driving cars.
He said the competition between Uber and Lyft has led them to "drive down" the price of rides and pay to drivers "as if they're two kids with lemonade stands."
"I know they have to generate more revenue," he said.
Lyft jumps its Wall Street debut
Lyft jumps its Wall Street debut
On Thursday, Lyft priced its initial public offering at $72 a share which puts the company's valuation at about $24 billion. The price was higher than previously proposed. On Friday, Lyft began trading at $87.24 a share on the Nasdaq, a more than 20% increase over its IPO price.
But Lyft suffered monumental losses last year, totaling $911 million -- reportedly more than any other US startup in the year prior to its IPO.
"By going public, it makes it more clear it is beholden to capital, not less so. ... I can't believe anyone would think things will improve when the companies IPO," said Katie Wells, an urban studies foundation postdoctoral fellow at Georgetown University who researches the social and economic effects of on-demand services.
Drivers already feel they're being squeezed
Krueger said he relies on his internet marketing company to make money, and supplements that with driving up to 20 hours per week.
"The taxi industry was really ripe for anyone to do better," he said. "They found a way to do it a heck of a lot better and cut the price by about half, instead of a reasonable price deduction.
"They may be able to sustain this pay to drivers right now because the economy is such that there are a lot of people scrambling for work," he added. "Once they can't turn on the faucet and get more drivers in the market, they'll have to increase the rates."
The ride-hailing business model is dependent on attracting and retaining drivers. In its financial documents filed ahead of its IPO, Lyft referenced how dependent it is on its drivers.
"We believe that our ability to compete effectively depends upon many factors both within and beyond our control, including ... our ability to attract and retain qualified drivers and riders," the filing said.
Here's who will get rich from the Lyft IPO
Here's who will get rich from the Lyft IPO
A Stanford University study examining the Uber driver gender pay gap noted that more than 60% of drivers across the country quit after 6 months. Additionally, the competition for consumers means the companies are engaged in pricing wars, using discounted prices to incentivize riders.
As a token of goodwill to drivers, Lyft granted cash bonuses to drivers who meet certain ride thresholds -- $1,000 for 10,000 trips or $10,000 for 20,000 trips -- ahead of the IPO that they could opt to put toward stock.
San Francisco-based Lyft driver Jay Cradeur, who is eligible for the smaller of the bonuses, told CNN that the gesture is merely "a very low budget, high visibility public relations campaign."
Cradeur, who previously told CNN that he'd opt to put the money toward stock in the company "just for the giggles," said that if his shares hit $100, he plans to sell. Drivers like Cradeur who were eligible for the bonus program were given a deadline to purchase shares on Thursday evening once the final pricing was set. He's not so bullish on the company's future: "Long-term, I'm not sure how Lyft is going to make money."
The company intends to deploy self-driving rides in the next 5 years, but for now, its rides are provided by drivers, a model that has proven to be a money-losing endeavor so far.
According to Arun Sundararajan, a professor at New York University's Stern School of Business, a significant part of the ongoing relationship with drivers is going to be shaped by how Lyft manages investor expectations.
On-demand companies rewired our lives. Now they must survive Wall Street
On-demand companies rewired our lives. Now they must survive Wall Street
"If Lyft falls into the trap of trying to manage short-term earnings and expectations, it's probably going to also succumb to pressure to cut driver costs," he said.
He added that both Uber and Lyft need to convince investors that, in the next 5 years, they can carve out a bigger portion of consumers' transportation budgets.
"Amazon is a good example here," Sundararajan said. "They lost money for 10 to 15 years while slowly training consumers to trust an online platform for more and more of their purchases."
But it's clear Lyft's drivers are a big key to gaining consumer trust and brand affinity.
"The driver is the face of the brand," he said. "The entire experience is controlled by the person whose car you get into -- if they're projecting, 'I'm underpaid and unhappy,' that's not going to be a good experience."
AI
