![](http://investorshub.advfn.com/images/default_ih_profile2_4848.jpg?cb=0)
Friday, March 08, 2019 6:39:24 PM
A recent Dallas Morning News editorial blamed so-called patent trolls for Apple closing two stores in Plano and Frisco. My law firm represents several of the businesses described as "opportunistic companies" that "exploit the courts and our patent law." In fact, Apple is the opportunistic company.
Apple has lost multiple trials in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, including some cases won by my law firm, Caldwell Cassady & Curry. Our verdicts against Apple include $533 million (2015), $625 million (2016), $302 million (2016), $22 million (2016) and $502 million (2018).
In three of these trials, we represented Nevada-based VirnetX Inc. in cases involving the technology that enables the popular FaceTime feature to work on Apple's iPhones and other company products. VirtnetX, a publicly traded company, owns a valuable patent portfolio that covers secure communications technology, and its patented ideas originated with a group of inventors from Science Applications International Corp., the respected defense contractor and technology supplier.
One of the main inventors of VirnetX's patented technology is a former chief system architect and assistant vice president at SAIC. Another holds a Ph.D. in electrical engineering and previously worked as assistant vice president and division manager at SAIC.
The reason Apple was sued is because the company has never licensed VirnetX's technology. Instead, Apple has used its vast resources to drag VirnetX through trial after trial and appeal after appeal. Despite having had multiple opportunities, Apple has never won at trial against VirnetX because it has never been able to muster a defense that jurors found credible.
In 2013, Apple modified FaceTime to avoid infringing VirnetX's patents. This redesign was so expensive that it was abandoned after only three months, and Apple again modified FaceTime to resume infringing VirnetX's patents. Meanwhile, Apple misrepresented this fact in litigation and claimed that it was continuing to use its expensive redesign. After the truth was uncovered, a Federal District Court judge found that Apple had tried to conceal its infringement. But to this day — after nearly a decade in court — Apple has never paid VirnetX one penny for using its technology.
Who is really the "opportunistic company" here? Apple has made more than a trillion dollars selling products that rely on VirnetX's technology. Even if it did not originally intend to infringe VirnetX's patents, Apple certainly made a cold calculation to resume its infringement after its redesign failed —knowing that it would take VirnetX years to get any relief in court.
And who is really "exploiting" the courts? For one, it's entirely prudent to file cases in a proper legal venue such as the Eastern District, where the judges are very experienced in patent law and adept at identifying and managing any cases that are not brought with good reason. It's also important to note that, at any point in time, Apple could have decided to take responsibility and license VirnetX's technology on fair terms. Instead, it has engaged in litigation misconduct while trying to string out the proceedings to avoid paying anything.
If Apple officials want to move out of Frisco, that is their prerogative. But let's not pretend that Apple is a victim.
Recent AAPL News
- Apple Joins OpenAI Board, Logitech President Opts Out of Reelection, and More News • IH Market News • 07/03/2024 10:59:39 AM
- U.S. Stocks Close Higher; Nasdaq Outperforms • IH Market News • 07/01/2024 09:10:17 PM
- Dow Dips, Nasdaq Gains, Oil Prices Rise • IH Market News • 06/26/2024 11:00:03 AM
- SolarEdge Stock Falls 13%, Wegovy Approved in China, Grail Nasdaq Debut, Apple Rejects Meta Chatbot • IH Market News • 06/25/2024 10:36:11 AM
- UPS Divests Coyote Logistics in $1.025 Billion Deal with RXO, Under Armour Agrees to $434 million Settlement, and More News • IH Market News • 06/24/2024 11:00:20 AM
- Trump Media Resells Stocks and Warrants; KB Home Exceeds Q2 Expectations, and More News • IH Market News • 06/20/2024 10:55:11 AM
- Apple The Exchange TRX to welcome its first customers this Saturday, June 22, in Kuala Lumpur • Business Wire • 06/20/2024 02:00:00 AM
- Nvidia Overtakes Microsoft To Become World’s Most Valuable Company • IH Market News • 06/19/2024 09:32:08 AM
- Fisker Files for Bankruptcy, Chegg Stocks Rise on 23% Workforce Reduction, and More • IH Market News • 06/18/2024 11:02:13 AM
- Goldman Sachs Raises S&P 500 Forecast for 2024; Disney Secures Deadpool & Wolverine in Chinese Cinemas, and More • IH Market News • 06/17/2024 10:49:12 AM
- Adobe Soars 15% Pre-Market; Visa and Mastercard Encounter Hurdles in $30 Billion Agreement, and More • IH Market News • 06/14/2024 11:21:47 AM
- Tesla Surges 5% in Pre-Market; Virgin Galactic Drops 9% Following Reverse Stock Split, and More News • IH Market News • 06/13/2024 11:24:25 AM
- Tamer Than Expected Inflation Data May Spark Early Rally On Wall Street • IH Market News • 06/12/2024 01:07:00 PM
- Paramount Ends Skydance Talks, Oracle Shares Surge 8.7% on New Partnerships, and More News • IH Market News • 06/12/2024 11:19:10 AM
- U.S. Futures Rise on Fed Decision; Oil Gains on Demand Forecasts • IH Market News • 06/12/2024 11:13:28 AM
- Nasdaq, S&P 500 Recover From Early Weakness To Reach Record Highs • IH Market News • 06/11/2024 08:49:55 PM
- FDA Panel Supports Eli Lilly’s Donanemab, Rio Tinto Expands Stake in Boyne Smelters, and More News • IH Market News • 06/11/2024 11:11:40 AM
- Apple extends its privacy leadership with new updates across its platforms • Business Wire • 06/10/2024 09:40:00 PM
- Apple empowers developers and fuels innovation with new tools and resources • Business Wire • 06/10/2024 09:00:00 PM
- macOS Sequoia takes productivity and intelligence on Mac to new heights • Business Wire • 06/10/2024 06:43:00 PM
- watchOS 11 brings powerful health and fitness insights, and even more personalization and connectivity • Business Wire • 06/10/2024 06:43:00 PM
- iPadOS 18 introduces powerful new intelligence features and apps designed for Apple Pencil • Business Wire • 06/10/2024 06:43:00 PM
- iOS 18 makes iPhone more personal, capable, and intelligent than ever • Business Wire • 06/10/2024 06:43:00 PM
- Introducing Apple Intelligence, the personal intelligence system that puts powerful generative models at the core of iPhone, iPad, and Mac • Business Wire • 06/10/2024 06:43:00 PM
- visionOS 2 brings new spatial computing experiences to Apple Vision Pro • Business Wire • 06/10/2024 06:43:00 PM
Freedom Holdings Corporate Update; Announces Management Has Signed Letter of Intent • FHLD • Jul 3, 2024 9:00 AM
EWRC's 21 Moves Gaming Studios Moves to SONY Pictures Studios and Green Lights Development of a Third Upcoming Game • EWRC • Jul 2, 2024 8:00 AM
BNCM and DELEX Healthcare Group Announce Strategic Merger to Drive Expansion and Growth • BNCM • Jul 2, 2024 7:19 AM
NUBURU Announces Upcoming TV Interview Featuring CEO Brian Knaley on Fox Business, Bloomberg TV, and Newsmax TV as Sponsored Programming • BURU • Jul 1, 2024 1:57 PM
Mass Megawatts Announces $220,500 Debt Cancellation Agreement to Improve Financing and Sales of a New Product to be Announced on July 11 • MMMW • Jun 28, 2024 7:30 AM
VAYK Exited Caribbean Investments for $320,000 Profit • VAYK • Jun 27, 2024 9:00 AM