Fannie Mae-No Politics (FNMA)

[cooler_heads]

Taken from another board.

Credit-cherzeca

“I believe it would be a violation of the judicial oath for collins en banc to find fhfa constitutionally structured. the judicial power under article III extends to "cases and controversies", and collins is a controversy in which no party is seeking a decision that fhfa is constitutionally structured...only amici are asking for that...and amici are not parties to the case and controversy before collins en banc. Ps still have to win on standing and redressability, and get awarded retrospective relief (void NWS). but Ps cannot lose on whether fhfa is unconstitutionally structured.”