This could actually be a big influence to use fuel cells if people actually put two and two together.
19 3'
New Study Looks At Managing Grid Frequency Fluctuations From Renewables
January 12th, 2018 by Steve Hanley
The electrical grid is not something most people think about. Flip the switch, the lights come on. If they don’t, call the electric company. End of story. But the grid is actually a hugely complex organism, one that requires close attention to keep the electricity flowing at the right voltage and frequency.
Frequency is a concept unknown to most people. Alternating current flows first one way and then the other. The number of times a second that transition takes place is expressed in hertz. In Europe, the standard is 50 hertz. In North America, it is 60 hertz. The name comes from Heinrich Rudolf Hertz, the first person to provide conclusive proof of the existence of electromagnetic waves. Frequency stability is important because fluctuations can interfere with the proper operation of many electronic devices.
It is common to hear people say that renewables like solar and wind disrupt the grid because they vary in voltage and frequency depending on wind speed and cloud cover. There are also concerns about microgrids disrupting the stability of the larger utility grid. Researchers at the Juelich Research Center and the Max Planck Institute for Dynamics and Self-Organization in Germany have studied the electrical grids in Europe, Japan, and the US, and come up with some surprising findings.
“The first surprise was that the grid showed particularly strong fluctuations every 15 minutes,” says Dirk Witthaut of the Juelich Institute of Energy and Climate Research.”This is the exact time frame during which generators on the European electricity market agree on a new distribution for the electricity generated — this alters how much electricity is fed into the grid, and where. In Europe at least, power trading therefore plays a key role in balancing grid frequency fluctuations.”
Second, the researchers found that frequency fluctuations did not follow the mathematically predicted model. Instead, they tend to be larger than expected. Are renewables responsible for that difference in behavior? The study found that renewables do in fact lead to greater grid fluctuations. “For example, the share of wind and solar generation in the United Kingdom is much higher than in the USA, leading to greater fluctuations in grid frequency,” explains Witthaut. Based on their research, the scientists recommend increased investment in primary controls and demand controls.
What surprised the researches was that fluctuations from power trading were larger than those from renewables. In other words, the grid is already dealing with frequency fluctuations that are larger than those caused by renewables.
More inHome
Cryptocurrency’s Electrical Demand Will Drop Drastically
Spin Electric Bicycles Removes The Need For Bikeshare Stations
World’s Coral Reefs Reaching The Point Of No Return
What Do Elon Musk, Bono, & Tom Petty Share In Common? Of Square Pegs & Round Holes
Pic + Video — Inside Fully Autonomous GM/Cruise Taxi
Next, the scientists turned their attention to microgrids, and what they found is not such good news. “Our study indicates that dividing large and thus very slow grids — such as the synchronous grid of Continental Europe — into microgrids will cause larger frequency fluctuations,” says Benjamin Schaefer of the Max Planck Institute. “Technically, microgrids are therefore only an option if today’s very stringent frequency standards were to be relaxed.”
Relaxing those standards would require a significant redesign of many electronic devices and could damage existing equipment. That finding suggests better ways of managing frequency fluctuations will be needed before a distributed grid composed of many microgrids can become a reality.
Tags: demand control, electrical grid, frequency fluctuation, Juelich Research Center, Max Planck Institute, microgrid, primary control
About the Author
Steve Hanley
Steve writes about the interface between technology and sustainability from his home in Rhode Island. You can follow him on Google + and on Twitter.
Comments
TODAY INHOME
CLEAN POWER
New Study Looks At Managing Grid Frequency Fluctuations From Renewables
BY STEVE HANLEY
CLIMATE CHANGE
Cryptocurrency’s Electrical Demand Will Drop Drastically
BY MICHAEL BARNARD
CLEAN TRANSPORT
Spin Electric Bicycles Removes The Need For Bikeshare Stations
BY NICOLAS ZART
CLIMATE CHANGE
World’s Coral Reefs Reaching The Point Of No Return
BY JAMES AYRE
CLEAN POWER
What Do Elon Musk, Bono, & Tom Petty Share In Common? Of Square Pegs & Round Holes
BY STEVE BAKKER
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Pic + Video — Inside Fully Autonomous GM/Cruise Taxi
BY JAMES AYRE
CLEAN POWER
Tesla Solar Roof Tile Mass Production Began Last Month, Surveying Of Homes Of Deposit Holders Has Begun
BY JAMES AYRE
BICYCLES
You Can Now Legally Ride Your UBCO 2×2 Utility Electric Bike On Streets
BY NICOLAS ZART
BATTERIES
Honda Clarity PHEV Details, Feedback, & Initial Review From New Owner
BY STEVE HANLEY
CLEAN POWER
China Sitting Pretty To Dominate New Clean Energy Future, Claims IEEFA
BY JOSHUA S HILL
CLEAN POWER
South Australia Approves World’s Largest Single-Tower Thermal Solar Plant
BY JOSHUA S HILL
CLEAN POWER
Trump Suggests US “Could Conceivably Go Back” To Paris Agreement
BY JOSHUA S HILL
CLEAN TRANSPORT
Crowd Charging — New Pilot Project In Denmark
BY JESPER BERGGREEN
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Intel’s Mobileye Self-Driving Vehicle Systems To Go Into 2 Million BMW, Nissan, & Volkswagen Cars Over The Near Term
BY JAMES AYRE
CARS
Teslanomics Predicts 192,576 Tesla Model 3 Sedans Will Be Manufactured In 2018
BY STEVE HANLEY
AVIATION
Boeing Shows Off Prototype Unmanned Electric Vertical-Takeoff-&-Landing Cargo Aircraft
BY JAMES AYRE
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Ford Partnering With Postmates In Self-Driving Car Sector
BY JAMES AYRE
CARS
Good News, Bad News: The Saga Of The Ford F-150
BY STEVE HANLEY
CLIMATE CHANGE
New York City Sues 5 Major Oil Companies For Climate Change Related Damages
BY STEVE HANLEY
CLEAN TRANSPORT
Workhorse W-15 Orders Now Open To The Public
BY STEVE HANLEY
BUILDINGS
Zero Is The Hero: Zero Net Energy Buildings Reach New Communities, Promising Savings & Renewable Energy
BY JOHN FARRELL
BATTERIES
Wind & Solar + Storage Prices Smash Records
BY CHRISTOPHER ARCUS
CARS
Your 2017 Electric Car Sales Projections Revisited, … & 2018 Projections!
BY ZACHARY SHAHAN
GRID
Researchers Determine Future Climate Change Will Make Power Outages More Costly
BY JOSHUA S HILL
AIR QUALITY
Renewable Energy Has Many Benefits For People, The Economy, & The Environment
BY JAKE RICHARDSON
CLEAN POWER
Siemens Gamesa To Deliver 8-Megawatt Turbines To 500 Megawatt French Offshore Wind Farm
BY JOSHUA S HILL
CLIMATE CHANGE
Damages From US Disasters Totaled $306 Billion In 2017
BY STEVE HANLEY
BICYCLES
Cleantech News Roundup: Audi Truck, Tesla Autopilot 2, Bioplastics, Volvo Sustainability, & Hippie Pants
BY DEREK MARKHAM
CLEAN TRANSPORT
How EV Safe Charge Went From Helping A Few To Becoming A Full-Fledged Company
BY NICOLAS ZART
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Navistar Aims To Have More E-Trucks Than Tesla On The Road By 2025
BY ADAM JOHNSTON
CLIMATE CHANGE
Water-Based Air Conditioning Slashes Energy Usage & Uses No Refrigerants
BY STEVE HANLEY
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Uber Hires Former Tesla Battery Engineer For Flying Taxi Program
BY STEVE HANLEY
CARS
EV History: 100-Year-Old Ads For Pope Waverly Electric Cars
BY JO BORRÁS
CARS
This Classic Volvo 850 Is Also A Tiny House On Wheels
BY JO BORRÁS
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Fisker EMotion Revealed At CES 2018
BY STEVE HANLEY
CLEAN POWER
US Renewable Energy Hits The Ground Running After FERC Debacle
BY TINA CASEY
CARS
The Benefits Of An Electric Vehicle Road Trip … In The Middle East
BY ZACHARY SHAHAN
CARS
The Honda Clarity PHEV — Part Deux
BY STEVE HANLEY
CLIMATE CHANGE
How Much Longer Does South Florida Have Until The Real Estate Apocalypse Begins?
BY JAMES AYRE
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Toyota e-Palette Combines Electric Mobility, Roving Billboards, & Pizza
BY STEVE HANLEY
CLIMATE CHANGE
Tech Industry To Support Net Neutrality In Legal Slugfest
BY STEVE HANLEY
CLEAN POWER
US Solar Imports See Upswing With Solar Tariffs Waiting In The Wings
BY ADAM JOHNSTON
CLEAN TRANSPORT
The Sinclair C5 Gets A Deep Dive On The 99% Invisible Podcast
BY JO BORRÁS
CARS
Mercedes-Benz Hires Linkin Park To Develop The Sounds Of Its Electric Cars
BY JO BORRÁS
CLEAN TRANSPORT
Converted Double-Decker Bus Becomes Rolling Restaurant & Bar
BY JO BORRÁS
CARS
This Tesla Model S Owner Is Having It Converted Into A Station Wagon
BY JO BORRÁS
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Nissan Brain-to-Vehicle Technology, New Nissan LEAF, & Nissan IMx At CES
BY CYNTHIA SHAHAN
AIR QUALITY
UK Coal Phase-Out Plan — Good News Tinged With Timidity
BY STEVE HANLEY
CLIMATE CHANGE
Join the Fossil Free Fast Climate Resistance Movement On January 31
BY STEVE HANLEY
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Volkswagen Group & Aurora Announce Self-Driving Strategic Partnership At CES 2018
BY CYNTHIA SHAHAN
CLEAN POWER
Happy Responses To FERC’s Unanimous Rejection Of Coal & Nuclear Subsidy Plan Proposed By US Energy Secretary Rick Perry (+ FERC Statements)
BY JOSHUA S HILL
COAL
FERC Thumbs Its Nose At Rick Perry’s “Grid Resiliency” Plan
BY STEVE HANLEY
BUILDINGS
The Next Energy Frontier: Cutting Fossil Fuel Use in Buildings
BY CAROLYN FORTUNA
CARS
#1 Tesla Model S, #2 Tesla Model X, #3 Chevy Bolt — 2017’s US Electric Car Sales Winners
BY ZACHARY SHAHAN
AVIATION
SureFly Electric Helicopter … BMW i3 Nags Amongst Awesomeness … 20 Plug-In Hybrids (Top 20 CleanTechnica Stories of the Week)
BY ZACHARY SHAHAN
CARS
Classic Shelby Cobra Gets Powerful Electric Makeover
BY JO BORRÁS
CLEAN TRANSPORT
Energica Ego Chosen By MotoGP For New Electric Motorcycle Race Series
BY JO BORRÁS
CARS
Is The Infiniti Q Inspiration Concept The New Electric Infiniti?
BY JO BORRÁS
CARS
220 MPH Genovation GXE Electric Corvette Will Debut At CES (Video)
BY JO BORRÁS
GREEN ECONOMY
Green Bond Issuance Touches Highest-Ever $120 Billion In 2017
BY SAURABH MAHAPATRA
CLEAN POWER
India Tenders 1.2 Gigawatts Of Solar Capacity In First Week Of 2018
BY SAURABH MAHAPATRA
CLEAN POWER
Wind Energy Tariffs In India Fall 30% In 10 Months
BY SAURABH MAHAPATRA
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Byton Concept At 2018 CES: Is It The Future Of Driving?
BY STEVE HANLEY
Next Section
Electric Car Reviews
Classic version
marfeel logo
Cryptocurrency’s Electrical Demand Will Drop Drastically
January 12th, 2018 by Michael Barnard
The high electricity consumption of bitcoin has been widely reported, with one widely reported estimate having it consume more electricity than 159 countries. However, this is a temporary problem with cryptocurrencies, especially blockchain, and not an immutable feature.
HOME ELECTRIC CAR REVIEWS EXCLUSIVES POWER TRANSPORT ABOUT ELECTRIC CARS SUBSCRIBE
Cleantech News — Solar, Wind, EV News (#1 Source) | CleanTechnica logo
11:11AM
I wonder if anybody we'll take the time to figure out that fuel cells don't have the fluctuations that wind and solar do and make that point.
NEXT ARTICLE
Cleantech News — Solar, Wind, EV News (#1 Source) | CleanTechnica logo
HOME
ELECTRIC CAR REVIEWS
EXCLUSIVES
POWER
TRANSPORT
ABOUT
ELECTRIC CARS
SUBSCRIBE
