Friday, January 05, 2018 9:10:57 PM
Wells Fargo Earns New Ire from Bank Overseers
Friday 5 January 2018
By Emily Glazer
Banking regulators have grown increasingly disenchanted with Wells Fargo & Co. and in mid-2017 downgraded one part of a secret assessment of the bank's health and strength, according to people familiar with the decision.
The assessment -- known as a bank's CAMELS score -- ranks a firm on a variety of measures including capital, management and liquidity. The scores are confidential and can affect the level of insurance payments a bank must make as well as the level of regulatory oversight of a firm.
The reduction in the management component of Wells Fargo's CAMELS score, which hasn't been previously reported, reflected concerns about Wells Fargo's management and its ability to manage risk, the people familiar with the decision said.
The downgrade occurred as Wells Fargo continued to grapple with issues related to how it treats customers. Improper sales practices resulted in potentially 3.5 million accounts opened without customers' knowledge, while more than 550,000 auto-loan and mortgage customers were potentially overcharged for products.
Regulators' concerns focus on the bank's overall approach to catching and preventing problems that can harm customers.
The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency has been weighing a new enforcement action against the bank related to such risk controls, according to people familiar with the matter. A decision could be made in coming weeks and is likely to result in an enforcement action, these people said. If this happens, Wells Fargo may also be required to pay tens of millions of dollars as part of any settlement, one of these people said.
A Wells Fargo spokeswoman declined to comment on the bank's CAMELS rating or any potential OCC actions.
The spokeswoman said the bank is "very focused on prudent and effective risk management" and continues to enhance those matters. She cited the bank's work to centralize risk-management functions for better oversight; create a conduct-management office to protect employees and customers; and build centers of excellence in areas like testing and validation.
An OCC spokesman declined to comment on "supervisory matters pertaining to any specific institution."
The possibility of a regulatory sanction follows months of back and forth between the bank and the OCC over how Wells Fargo assesses risks, according to people familiar with the process. During that time, Wells Fargo has had to bring in an outside consultant to try to revamp its procedures and has had to undo some structural changes made in response to the revelation of the sales-practices scandal in September 2016.
That scandal led to an enforcement action with regulators and kicked off a public and political firestorm around the bank. It also prompted Wells Fargo to examine its businesses and practices, which led last year to the disclosure of additional problems related to auto-loan and mortgage charges to customers. The bank is in the process of refunding more than $100 million to customers.
The issues continue to weigh on the bank in a variety of ways. In 2017, Wells Fargo was the worst performing of the biggest U.S. banks; its shares rose 10%, 6 percentage points below the performance of the KBW Bank Index and 9 percentage points below that of the S&P 500.
In addition, Wells Fargo continues to make changes to its management. The bank recently pushed out regional executive John Sotoodeh. He had led Wells Fargo's retail-banking business in the Los Angeles area during a time several years ago when questionable employee behavior was rampant, according to people familiar with the matter.
Tracy Kidd, who led human resources for the retail bank, and Deanna Lindquist, who was head of the legal department's employment group, are also no longer with the bank, these people said.
The now-former executives didn't respond to requests for comment.
Another Wells Fargo spokeswoman confirmed the individuals no longer work for the bank.
For regulators, the number and scope of problems within different areas of the bank and the difficulty its management has had in addressing them suggest problems at the core of the way Wells Fargo manages risk, people familiar with the concerns said.
In mid-2017, the OCC downgraded one element in Wells Fargo's CAMELS rating, according to people familiar with the rating. The M component of this rating, which stands for Management, was downgraded to a 3 from a 2, some of these people said. The ratings are ranked on a scale from 1 to 5, with 5 being the worst.
The downgrade to a 3 signifies that oversight "needs improvement," based on factors including the sales-practices scandal and problems in the auto-lending and mortgage businesses, the people said. The 2 rating had indicated "satisfactory management."
The adjustment also included a downgrade of the bank's credit-risk rating to "insufficient" in late 2016due to a lack of policies, procedures and documentation, one of the people said.
It isn't publicly known whether the bank's composite CAMELS rating moved up or down in the past year. But the management-category rating "is given special consideration when assigning a composite rating," according to OCC guidelines.
One particular point of contention for regulators was that issues related to risk management that resulted in formal warnings to the bank hadn't been resolved, the people familiar with the decision said. Scrutiny over these issues escalated in mid-November when the OCC sent the bank's board a letter warning of a formal enforcement action known as a consent order, and cited the risk-management problems.
Wells Fargo responded to the OCC's letter in early December, detailing changes it has made in the past year, The Wall Street Journal reported.
The problem for the OCC, people familiar with the matter said, relates to the way the bank's corporate arm manages and oversees potential risks in individual businesses.
Regulators believe that Wells Fargo, which for years had operated through a fairly decentralized structure, failed to build such a functioning line of defense, people familiar with the matter said.
Write to Emily Glazer at emily.glazer@wsj.com
Successful Trading is the art of minimizing long term risk and maximizing capital allocation.
Recent WFC News
- CNOOC Oil Field Discovery in South China Sea, Grifols Surges 18% After KPMG Approval, and Latest News • IH Market News • 03/08/2024 11:19:59 AM
- Wells Fargo to Launch Autograph Journey(SM) Card Designed for Frequent Travelers • PR Newswire (US) • 03/06/2024 01:03:00 PM
- Futures Pointing To Continued Weakness On Wall Street • IH Market News • 03/05/2024 02:03:27 PM
- Flexible Financing to Provide Access to Rapidly Deployable EV Charging Stations Across the U.S. • Business Wire • 02/28/2024 02:00:00 PM
- Two-thirds of Americans have decreased spending due to economy, Wells Fargo Money Study finds • Business Wire • 02/27/2024 02:00:00 PM
- Doug Braunstein to Join Wells Fargo as Vice Chairman • Business Wire • 02/27/2024 02:00:00 PM
- Expedia Announces 1,500 Job Cuts; Hims & Hers Surges 19.8% Post Financial Results, and More News • IH Market News • 02/27/2024 11:15:07 AM
- Wells Fargo & Company Declares Cash Dividends on Preferred Stock • Business Wire • 02/16/2024 01:15:00 PM
- Wells Fargo to Present at the UBS Financial Services Forum • Business Wire • 02/16/2024 01:00:00 PM
- Wells Fargo Confirms Termination of 2016 OCC Sales Practices Consent Order • Business Wire • 02/15/2024 04:39:00 PM
- Nasdaq Private Market Closes $62.4 Million Series B Financing, Led by Nasdaq, with New Investments from BNP Paribas, DRW Venture Capital, UBS, and Wells Fargo • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 02/08/2024 01:00:00 PM
- Wells Fargo & Company Announces Full Redemption of its Series R Preferred Stock and Related Depositary Shares • Business Wire • 02/06/2024 01:00:00 PM
- Wall Street Highlights: Intel’s Disappointing Quarterly Forecast, PayPal’s New AI Solutions for Merchants, and More • IH Market News • 01/26/2024 01:45:22 PM
- Santander, Ramirez & Co. and Mischler Financial Group Join DirectBooks • PR Newswire (US) • 01/24/2024 01:00:00 PM
- Wells Fargo & Company Announces Common Stock Dividend • Business Wire • 01/23/2024 07:45:00 PM
- Wall Street Highlights: Macy’s Announces Job Cuts, iRobot Shares Plummet Due to Planned Acquisition Block, and More • IH Market News • 01/19/2024 11:09:24 AM
- Wells Fargo on Track for Longest Losing Streak Since December 2018 -- Data Talk • Dow Jones News • 01/18/2024 03:35:00 PM
- Wells Fargo on Pace for Largest Percent Decrease Since May 2023 -- Data Talk • Dow Jones News • 01/12/2024 06:51:00 PM
- Wells Fargo Reports Fourth Quarter 2023 Financial Results • Business Wire • 01/12/2024 11:57:00 AM
- Wall Street Highlights: DocuSign Acquisition Battle, Tesla Berlin Production Halt, and More • IH Market News • 01/12/2024 11:10:50 AM
- New Research from Wells Fargo and The Female Quotient Explores Taboo Topics, Secret Numbers, and Differing Gender and Generations' Relationships to Money • PR Newswire (US) • 01/10/2024 01:03:00 PM
- Wall Street Highlights: Tesla Launches Restyled Model 3, VinFast Unveils Pickup Prototype, and More • IH Market News • 01/10/2024 11:21:31 AM
- New Report Finds Growth of Women Business Owners Outpaces the Market • Business Wire • 01/09/2024 02:00:00 PM
- Wall Street Highlights: HPE and Juniper Networks in Negotiations, Elliott Invests $1 Billion in Match Group, and More • IH Market News • 01/09/2024 11:12:25 AM
- Preview -- Barron's • Dow Jones News • 01/06/2024 11:15:00 PM
FEATURED Elevai Labs Launches E-commerce Portal to Support Rapid Growth as Stem Cell Exosome Disruptor in the $19.7 Billion Global Physician Dispensed Cosmeceutical Market • Mar 18, 2024 8:51 AM
FEATURED Prospera Energy Inc. Announces a 508% increase in the 2023 Proven Developed Producing (PDP) Reserve Valuation • Mar 18, 2024 8:09 AM
Greenlite Ventures Enters into Strategic Alliance with Woodway USA • GRNL • Mar 15, 2024 4:00 PM
HealthLynked Welcomes David Rosal as New Chief Financial Officer • HLYK • Mar 13, 2024 8:00 AM
ECGI Holdings, Inc. Announces Continued Efforts in Financial Optimization • ECGI • Mar 13, 2024 8:00 AM
PSYC Begins Business Overhaul Process with Consolidation of 10 Previously Issued Convertible Debentures • PSYC • Mar 13, 2024 7:13 AM