Home > Boards > US OTC > Banking and Finance > Fannie Mae (FNMA)

From   Today’s trade: Fannie Mae, as longstanding lawsuits

Public Reply | Private Reply | Keep | Last ReadPost New MsgNext 10 | Previous | Next
Brugee Member Profile
Followed By 6
Posts 93
Boards Moderated 0
Alias Born 11/03/13
160x600 placeholder
Brugee   Thursday, 09/14/17 07:00:05 AM
Re: None
Post # of 450611 


Today’s trade: Fannie Mae, as longstanding lawsuits are resolved

Jason Bond

September 13th, 2017 at 8:45 am

The back story: Fannie Mae (FNMA) has been embroiled in a pile of lawsuits for five years, starting in August 2012 with the infamous “Net Worth Sweep” scheme by the FHFA. The suits alleged that a government body unilaterally confiscating shareholder value of a publicly-traded enterprise was unconstitutional.

Essentially, at that time in 2012, the FHFA insisted the purpose of the “Sweep” was to prevent a “death spiral” in Fannie Mae. The U.S. Treasury has concurred with the FHFA, most recently in documents submitted in June to the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals.

The plaintiffs’ case against the FHFA was that the agency conspired to confiscate Fannie Mae’s future earnings while “winding down” the enterprise. And evidence has emerged to support that case, particularly in the most high-profile of the Fannie Mae lawsuits, filed by Fairholme Funds, a well-known value investor.

The Fairholme Funds – which own a substantial stake in FNMA preferred stock — appear to offer the most damaging arguments against the government’s contention that placing FNMA into conservatorship was necessary to “save” the institution. Just weeks after the Sweep scheme was uncovered in 2012, an email between FHFA officials was entered into evidence which contradicts the FHFA’s assertion that the agency planned a “wind down” at a future date; instead, it suggested that the sweep was done solely to justify a wind-down.

Since this revelation, more documents supporting Fairholme have emerged.  In an article, entitled, ‘More Documents, More Proof of a Scheme to Illegally Pilfer Fannie and Freddie’, other documents generated by the FHFA, Treasury and White House counsel support the ‘smoking gun’ email that implies that the sweep was a ruse to rob FNMA shareholders.

Why I’m buying/holding FNMA: I expect a successful outcome to the Fairholme case.

President Trump chose Steven Mnuchin as Secretary of the Treasuryin part to resolve FNMA in favor of stockholders. It’s a basic part of Trump’s ideological fabric, and of his administration; as a natural and avowed proponent of the free-enterprise system, the President is expected to bypass lengthy court trials and execute his own plan to restore shareholder rights to FNMA.

How the President’s plan will ultimately look is not clear, but taking a stake in an enterprise that trades at a laughable $2.9 billion while knowing that FNMA has sent the US Treasury a total of $160 billion of earnings from the ‘Sweep’ is a fantastic risk/reward bet that some or all of those earnings will come back to shareholders as these cases are resolved.

President Trump can’t save face by allowing the government to justify yanking shareholder Constitutional rights, so he can’t let the FHFA prevail.

How I’m playing it: I’m long 10,000 shares of FNMA at $2.52 and intend to add 10,000 shares, with a target of $10 or more long-term. Whether I simply make a good profit or the “profit of a lifetime,” FNMA is the most interesting and exciting trade I’ve come across in a very long time.


 Jason Bond runs and is a swing trader of small-cap stocks. At the time this was published on, as described in the article, he held 10,000 shares of FNMA, and was planning to double that position as described in the article. He no options or open orders in FNMA.

Recent PostsToday’s trade: Fannie Mae, as longstanding lawsuits are resolvedFollow-up: Financial Select Sector SPDR (XLF) callsWhy not: Short the market off of this week’s up-movesRaging Bull podcast: Jeff Bishop says Amazon effect has created year-end opportunity in retailOn the watch: the return of the breakout play in MU and ATVI

Archive  Select Month   September 2017    August 2017    July 2017    June 2017    May 2017    April 2017    March 2017    February 2017    December 2016  

Never Miss A Post


Market Movers by TradingView

Be a Better Stock Trader, Starting Today

Get the expert insights, tips and strategies you need to optimize your trading skills and profiles

Stock Picks

Our Raging Bull Experts have been featured on:

Get better stock picks and ideas with Raging Bull is the premier destination for both new or experienced active traders who are looking for stock picks, stock ideas, how to get started trading stocks, and overall stock market education. Our team is comprised of real millionaire stock traders who put their money to work everyday in the markets by actively trading penny stocks, ETF’s, options, small-cap stocks and biotech stocks.

Latest Articles

Today’s trade: Fannie Mae, as longstanding lawsuits are resolved

by Jason Bond - 18 hours ago

Read More

Follow-up: Financial Select Sector SPDR (XLF) calls

by Davis Martin - 18 hours ago

Read More

Contact Us

Raging Bull

835 E. Lamar Blvd. #263 Arlington, TX, 76011


© Copyright 2017, RagingBull - Refund Policy - Privacy Policy - Terms & Conditions - Disclaimer - Contact - Affiliates

Public Reply | Private Reply | Keep | Last ReadPost New MsgNext 10 | Previous | Next
Follow Board Follow Board Keyboard Shortcuts Report TOS Violation
Current Price
Detailed Quote - Discussion Board
Intraday Chart
+/- to Watchlist