Sunday, July 16, 2017 4:30:10 PM
Pimco sues Wells Fargo, claims MBS trustee ‘looted’ trusts to pay legal fees
Alison Frankel
Click on complaint in article link to read court filing.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-otc-pimco-idUSKBN19X2NV
(Reuters) - Several Pimco investment funds are accusing the mortgage-backed securities trustee Wells Fargo of misusing noteholder money to pay its own legal expenses.
In a newly filed complaint in Manhattan State Supreme Court, the Pimco funds are asking for a declaratory judgment that Wells Fargo is not entitled to use MBS trust money to fund its defense against noteholder claims that the bank breached its duties as an MBS trustee. Pimco’s lawyers at Bernstein Litowitz Berger & Grossmann allege that Wells Fargo has improperly reserved about $95 million across 20 MBS trusts.
The Pimco complaint is the latest wrinkle in increasingly complex litigation between MBS noteholders and trustees. Pimco is one of several major institutional investors pursuing Wells Fargo, Deutsche Bank, HSBC and other MBS trustees for supposedly failing to take action against MBS sponsors as the trusts began to lose money. As I’ve reported, noteholders have managed to get past trustee dismissal motions in several big cases in state and federal court, but still face the considerable obstacle of providing loan-specific proof that trustees were obliged to demand the repurchase of deficient underlying mortgages and didn’t live up to that obligation.
The trustees have aggressively defended the cases. In May, for example, Wells Fargo’s lawyers at Jones Day filed third-party complaints in Manhattan federal court against the advisory arms of three of the funds suing the trustee, claiming that the advisory firms knew as much as Wells Fargo about problems in the MBS market and should be jointly liable if the trustee is socked with a judgment for tort damages.
The new Pimco complaint alleges that Wells Fargo is improperly paying its lawyers in the trustee breach cases with money that rightfully belongs to noteholders. The trustee’s litigation reserves were exposed in April, according to the complaint, when an entity called New Residential Investment Corp exercised rights to call in Wells-overseen trusts with an unpaid principal balance of about $309.5 million. The complaint alleges that Wells Fargo withheld $57.2 million to establish “trustee reserve accounts” to cover legal expenses stemming from litigation over its conduct as trustee. (Nomura analysts disclosed the Wells Fargo reserve accounts in a report in June.)
Pimco contends Wells Fargo is not permitted, under the MBS contracts for the 11 trusts at issue in its suit, to use trust money to defend against allegations of willful wrongdoing, bad faith or negligence. Those are precisely the claims at issue in noteholder litigation against the MBS trustee, according to the complaint. “Neither the (MBS contracts) nor the law permit Wells Fargo’s taxing of the investors it was supposed to protect to indemnify itself and to finance its actual and expected defense costs,” the complaint said.
Pimco’s suit isn’t the first time a noteholder has raised questions about the funding of an MBS trustee’s defense in this wave of investor litigation. In March, lawyers for Royal Park Investment (RPI) moved for a court order requiring MBS trustee Deutsche Bank to disclose any legal fees and expenses it had billed to MBS trusts at issue in RPI’s case against the trustee. Like Pimco in the new Wells Fargo case, RPI and its lawyers from Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd claimed that the trust contracts did not indemnify Deutsche Bank for claims of negligence or misconduct.
Deutsche Bank’s lawyers from Morgan Lewis & Bockius countered that the trust agreements expressly indemnify the MBS trustee from fees and costs associated with its duties as trustee. The judge overseeing the dispute, U.S. Magistrate Barbara Moses of Manhattan, ruled that RPI’s request was outside the scope of her jurisdiction. She suggested that if RPI wanted to pursue the matter, it should file a preliminary injunction motion – although she also warned at oral argument that if she were RPI, “I wouldn’t be terribly optimistic about the outcome of that motion.” (There’s no indication in the RPI docket that Robbins Geller filed a preliminary injunction motion on Deutsche Bank’s legal fees.)
Wells Fargo sent an email statement on the new Pimco suit. The bank said that as an MBS trustee, it “is entitled to indemnification of its legal fees and expenses under the contractual agreements at issue. We believe the lawsuit filed by the Pimco funds has no merit and will be vigorously defending the claim.”
Pimco counsel Blair Nicholas of Bernstein Litowitz declined to provide a statement.
Recent RITM News
- Rithm Capital Corp. Completes Acquisition of Computershare Mortgage Services Inc., Expanding Newrez LLC’s Servicing Portfolio and Subservicing Platform • Business Wire • 05/02/2024 06:00:00 PM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Completes Acquisition of Computershare Mortgage Services Inc., Expanding Newrez LLC’s Servicing Portfolio and Subservicing Platform • Business Wire • 05/01/2024 08:15:00 PM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Announces First Quarter 2024 Results • Business Wire • 04/30/2024 10:45:00 AM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Schedules First Quarter 2024 Earnings Release and Conference Call • Business Wire • 04/18/2024 08:45:00 PM
- Sculptor Launches Captive CLO Equity Platform with Anchor Commitment from Rithm Capital • Business Wire • 04/18/2024 01:00:00 PM
- Genesis Capital Closes Largest Ever Rated Residential Transition Loan Securitization • Business Wire • 04/09/2024 08:47:00 PM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Declares First Quarter 2024 Common and Preferred Dividends • Business Wire • 03/20/2024 09:00:00 PM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Announces Early Tender Results for Its 6.250% Senior Unsecured Notes Due 2025 • Business Wire • 03/18/2024 10:30:00 AM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Announces Pricing of Offering of Senior Unsecured Notes • Business Wire • 03/05/2024 10:15:00 PM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Announces Proposed Offering of Senior Unsecured Notes • Business Wire • 03/04/2024 12:16:00 PM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Announces Commencement of Tender Offer for 6.250% Senior Unsecured Notes Due 2025 • Business Wire • 03/04/2024 12:15:00 PM
- Rithm Capital Corp. and Great Ajax Corp. Announce a Strategic Transaction • Business Wire • 02/26/2024 10:56:00 PM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Announces Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2023 Results • Business Wire • 02/07/2024 11:45:00 AM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Schedules Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2023 Earnings Release and Conference Call • Business Wire • 01/30/2024 11:00:00 AM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Announces Treatment of 2023 Taxable Dividends • Business Wire • 01/29/2024 10:00:00 PM
- David Werner Real Estate Investments Secures Long-term Lease Extension with Dow at Collegeville, Pennsylvania Life Sciences Campus • PR Newswire (US) • 01/16/2024 01:00:00 PM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Declares Fourth Quarter 2023 Common and Preferred Dividends • Business Wire • 12/12/2023 10:30:00 PM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Completes Acquisition of Sculptor Capital Management • Business Wire • 11/17/2023 01:41:00 PM
- Rithm Capital Partners with Darwin Homes to Form Innovative Single-Family Rental Management Technology Platform • Business Wire • 10/31/2023 12:30:00 PM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Enters into Amended Merger Agreement to Acquire Sculptor Capital Management For $12.70 Per Sculptor Class A Share • Business Wire • 10/27/2023 10:00:00 AM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Announces Third Quarter 2023 Results • Business Wire • 10/26/2023 10:45:00 AM
- Rithm Capital Issues Statement Regarding Latest Actions by Certain Former Executive Managing Directors of Sculptor • Business Wire • 10/18/2023 01:15:00 PM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Schedules Third Quarter 2023 Earnings Release and Conference Call • Business Wire • 10/17/2023 08:15:00 PM
- Rithm Capital Corp. Enters into Amended Definitive Merger Agreement to Acquire Sculptor Capital Management for $12.00 Per Sculptor Class A Share • Business Wire • 10/12/2023 11:34:00 AM
- Rithm Capital to Acquire Specialized Loan Servicing LLC • Business Wire • 10/02/2023 10:30:00 AM
VAYK Discloses Strategic Conversation on Potential Acquisition of $4 Million Home Service Business • VAYK • May 9, 2024 9:00 AM
Bantec's Howco Awarded $4.19 Million Dollar U.S. Department of Defense Contract • BANT • May 8, 2024 10:00 AM
Element79 Gold Corp Successfully Closes Maverick Springs Option Agreement • ELEM • May 8, 2024 9:05 AM
Kona Gold Beverages, Inc. Achieves April Revenues Exceeding $586,000 • KGKG • May 8, 2024 8:30 AM
Epazz plans to spin off Galaxy Batteries Inc. • EPAZ • May 8, 2024 7:05 AM
Moon Equity Holdings, Corp. Announces Acquisition of Wikolo, Inc. • MONI • May 7, 2024 9:48 AM