A study found smoking marijuana actually did make people lazier
The Conversation UK
Will Lawn, The Conversation UK
11h 2,384 4
marijuana cannabis weed pot joint light smoke
A man lights a marijuana joint at Dundas Square in Toronto April 20, 2007. Marijuana smokers gather on April 20 every year to publicly push for its legalizationMark Blinch/Reuters
I was gonna go to work but then I got high
I just got a new promotion but I got high
Now I'm selling dope and I know why
'Cause I got high
Because I got high
Because I got high
Afroman's 2001 hit Because I Got High tells a potentially important story: smoking cannabis makes you lazy and demotivated.
In fact, the fable of the lazy stoner has been around for decades. But is there good evidence in support of it?
Two studies we have been working on have investigated the claim that cannabis leads to reduced motivation. We found that when you give people the equivalent of one spliff's worth of cannabis, under controlled conditions in a laboratory, they are less willing to work for money.
In other words, they are not as motivated as usual. However, we also compared people who are addicted to cannabis with a control group (non-cannabis drug users). We found that when neither group had used drugs for at least 12 hours, they did not differ in their motivation for money.
Our results suggest that when you have recently smoked cannabis, it reduces your motivation in the short-term. On the other hand, long-term cannabis use may not impair your motivation, as long as you stop smoking it for at least 12 hours.
'Amotivational syndrome'
cannabis weed marijuana
A woman lights a joint as a group of cannabis advocates smoke marijuana and march down Broad Street toward the Wells Fargo Center on the final day of the Democratic National Convention in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, U.S., July 28, 2016.REUTERS/Dominick Reuter
In the late 1950s and 1960s, as cannabis became a popular recreational drug, academic reports of cannabis's "amotivational syndrome" appeared. Clinicians stated that "regular marihuana [sic] use may contribute to the development of more passive, inward turning, amotivational personality characteristics".
However, these reports simply relied on observations of cannabis users and their lazy behaviour. Research was needed to investigate the short and long-term effects of cannabis.
Early research into the short-term effects of cannabis on motivation surprisingly found both motivating and demotivating effects of cannabis.
Having said that, these studies were poorly controlled and sometimes rather bizarre in their design; one involved getting people stoned and asking them to make stools as quickly as possible.
A more recent study gave cannabis to people in a placebo-controlled experiment and reported reduced motivation for money. However, this experiment used a very small sample of five participants.
marijuana cannabis
Bob Leeds, co-owner of Sea of Green Farms, shows some of the marijuana he produces during a tour of his company's facility in Seattle, Washington June 30, 2014.REUTERS/Jason Redmond
Our new study used a double-blind, placebo-controlled design to examine the effects of cannabis on motivation for money in a larger sample of 17 participants.
Through a balloon, participants inhaled cannabis vapour on one occasion and a placebo cannabis vapour on a separate occasion. Straight after, they completed a task designed to measure their motivation for earning money.
This was a real-life task as the participants were given money they had earned at the end of the experiment. In each trial, they could decide whether to complete low or high-effort options to win varying sums of money.
The low-effort option involved pressing the spacebar key 30 times in seven seconds to win 50p. The high-effort option involved 100 space bar presses in 21 seconds for rewards varying from 80p to £2.
We found that people on cannabis were significantly less likely to choose the high-effort option. On average, volunteers on placebo chose the high-effort option 50% of the time for a £2 reward, whereas volunteers on cannabis only chose the high-effort option 42% of the time.
In other words, they had reduced motivation for the money available when they were stoned. Although it has been a long-held belief that getting high makes you lazy, this is the first time it has been reliably demonstrated using a suitable sample size.
No difference
marijuanan cannabis
Activist Ray Turmel holds a bag of medical marijuana while he smokes a marijuana cigarette, as he calls for the total legalization of marijuana, outside the building where the federal election Munk Debate on Canada's Foreign Policy is being held in Toronto, Canada, September 28, 2015.REUTERS/Mark Blinch
The question of whether long-term cannabis use makes people demotivated, even when they're not high, is a more difficult one to answer. We cannot carry out randomised controlled trials in which some people are given cannabis for ten years while another group receive placebo for ten years. That would, of course, be unethical.
Therefore, we have to rely on observational studies, where we look at associations between natural cannabis consumption and motivation levels.
Some previous research has failed to find a link between cannabis use and altered motivation, although in one study earlier cannabis consumption predicted later anhedonia (difficulty experiencing pleasure).
In our observational study (that is, one that does not have an experimental manipulation), we compared 20 people who were addicted to cannabis against a control group of 20 people who were not addicted to cannabis.
The control group used other drugs, including MDMA and cocaine, a similar amount to the cannabis group. These participants completed the same motivation task as in the previous study after they had been clean of all drugs (apart from tobacco and caffeine) for at least 12 hours. We found no difference between the groups in their willingness to work for money.
This suggests that long-term cannabis use may not reduce motivation after 12 hours of abstinence from the drug.
cannabis marijuana weed
A worker places newly prepared cigarettes filled with medical marijuana at a plantation near the northern Israeli town of Nazareth, in this May 28, 2013 file pictureREUTERS/Amir Cohen/Files
However, there are some important limitations with this study. Firstly, the sample sizes were small. Secondly, the study was cross-sectional, so we only investigated the participants at one point in time.
An improved study would have used a longitudinal design, in which people's motivation and cannabis use are measured at different time points as they grow up.
This would have allowed for a better understanding of how cannabis consumption affects future motivation. Longitudinal research is needed to draw stronger conclusions.
What do our results mean to the average cannabis user? After years of being told that getting high makes you lazier, we've provided some of the first solid evidence that it's true.
Importantly though, it doesn't eradicate your motivation altogether - it makes you slightly, yet significantly, more apathetic. On the bright side, your long-term cannabis use may not erode your drive like some people claim, so long as you can put your joint down for a while.
Will Lawn, Post-doctoral researcher, UCL
This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.
AI
