olddog According to your assumptions on LG must not have owed IDCC a thing for the use of 3G, then why did IDCC win the arbitration in fact why did IDCC seek to get paid for 3G? Now when IDCC won and even sought legal fees from the U.S. courts. If all IDCC won was a right to go to court they had that right from any day as anyone can sue anyone any time. No sane person would declare what was a win in the arbitration that only allowed you to sue them if necessary would ever make a statement that LG 3G was concluded and behind them. Those words are clear to me there is nothing more to be litigated that the LG 3G dispute was concluded and behind them. Further litigation would be a long way from concluded and behind them. You would tell the shareholders we won the no arbitration but you would never declare LG 3G is concluded and behind us. If they go to court I personally will spend my money to sue Merritt for misrepresenting the LG 3G dispute. JMO Mickey