I'm not sure we think it's broke, Churak. I think we believe it needs to be tweaked a bit. And yes, it surely does matter what you folks think. If that were not the case you would have simply seen an announcement of the new guidelines and not had this opportunity to present your opinion on the matter.
I think something is wrong when one poster asks a question of another poster, the other poster answers, and a mod or Admin has to delete both the question and answer because there is some technical TOS violation embedded in the original question and the underlying answer is deleted because it lacks context absent the original question on the board. That's the sort of thing that people can't understand.
That's just one example. It happens quite often.
It doesn't look like I'll be running out of things to do any time soon.