XpresSpa Group Inc (XSPA)

[h2145h]

For much insight on the case read the article in Ars technica entitled “After years of hype, patent troll Vringo demolished on appeal”. The comments are very informative about the reasoning of the judges..

IMO vringo is carrying out the purposes of the patent law but from the comments that appear sto be a minority view. Also IMO what seems obvious now certainly did not seem obvious in 1998 when the patent office did not think the patents were something obvious.