Friday, November 15, 2013 12:44:14 AM
Tough guys: Operation Sovereign Borders vs the PNG Solution
27 July 2013, 12.18pm AEST
Just when you thought being “tough on borders” couldn’t get any more serious, along comes the Coalition’s Operation Sovereign Borders. It’s got all the right elements of a plan: it’s an operation (with 12 separate government agencies under the central command of a 3-star general no less), highlights…
Author
Melissa Phillips
Honorary Fellow at University of Melbourne
Disclosure Statement [inside]
[can't reproduce]
Opposition leader Tony Abbott and immigration spokesman Scott
Morrison hope Australian voters prefer their policy. AAP/Dan Peled
Just when you thought being “tough on borders” couldn’t get any more serious, along comes the Coalition’s Operation Sovereign Borders .. http://www.tonyabbott.com.au/LatestNews/PressReleases/tabid/86/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/9311/Operation-Sovereign-Borders.aspx .
It’s got all the right elements of a plan: it’s an operation (with 12 separate government agencies under the central command of a 3-star general no less), highlights the centrality of national sovereignty .. http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-07-25/dunlop-the-only-border-security-we-have-left/4843500 .. and reinforces Howard-era sentiments about border control. So how does it stack up against the Rudd government’s Regional Resettlement Arrangement .. http://www.pm.gov.au/press-office/australia-and-papua-new-guinea-regional-settlement-arrangement ?
Both plans emphasise coordination. Coordination amongst operational agencies was a concern raised earlier by the Expert Panel on Asylum Seekers .. http://expertpanelonasylumseekers.dpmc.gov.au/ . This report focused on the need for coordination in the areas of regional cooperation for protection and asylum frameworks, and strategic dialogue with resettlement countries. It also recommended a whole-of-government approach on engagement with source countries including for the removal and return of failed asylum seekers.
On defence and security matters the Expert Panel suggested the development of joint operational guidelines for managing search and rescue activities in the region and to address the need for any further regional and national codification of arrangements across search and rescue jurisdictions. Even though the Expert Panel was led by Retired Air Marshal Chief Angus Houston, acting Chief of the Defence Force during the “children overboard” incident in 2001, it did not raise coordination between Australian government agencies cooperating on border security as an area in need of improvement.
The highly criticised Regional Resettlement Agreement .. http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jul/26/united-nations-agency-asylum-policy , approaches the issue of asylum seekers from a foreign policy perspective. This is no surprise given Kevin Rudd’s interest in this area and the precedent already set with offshore processing on Manus Island. It links success of the agreement with a possible increase in the offshore humanitarian program to 27,000 places. Under-pinning the whole agreement is an assumption that deterring people from coming to Australia will “send a message” to people trying to seek asylum in Australia. The social media campaign .. http://stream.aljazeera.com/story/201307222149-0022923 .. that accompanied the announcement of the Regional Resettlement Agreement was testimony to this objective.
Opposition Leader Tony Abbott has already been criticised for his alleged lack of diplomatic skills .. http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/federal-election-2013/in-veiled-swipe-at-tony-abbott-png-lashes-australian-politicians-for-impugning-the-dignity-of-its-leaders-20130724-2qj84.html .. when commenting upon the Regional Resettlement Agreement. Unsurprisingly then, Operation Sovereign Borders moves away from the foreign policy domain and presents a defence and security-centric response. It will, through a joint taskforce, allow for the turning back of boats .. http://theconversation.com/explainer-the-legality-of-turning-or-towing-back-asylum-boats-16201 .. where it is safe to do so and the deployment of additional vessels to relieve patrol vessels of passenger transfers. The plan also refers to increasing capacity at offshore processing centres on Manus Island and Nauru.
The Liberal party claims the need for this taskforce is because the “current multiplicity of agencies and reporting lines provides for conflicting strategies, disconnected systems, fractured accountability, inadequate information system, duplication, higher costs and turf wars”. The main evidence presented to support this claim is that of the case of people smuggler Captain Emad .. http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/people-smuggling-suspect-captain-emads-australian-visa-cancelled/story-fn59niix-1226442344176 .. which highlighted issues about cooperation between the Department of Immigration and Australian Federal Police. A commitment remains to regional cooperation on people smuggling through the Bali process. Similar to the Regional Resettlement Agreement, the Operation Sovereign Borders plan .. http://lpaweb-static.s3.amazonaws.com/Policies/OperationSovereignBorders_Policy.pdf , claims it will send a message to people smugglers and their prospective passengers.
Interestingly a similar defence-based option is at the preliminary stage of discussions in Europe for border guards .. http://ted.europa.eu/udl?uri=TED:NOTICE:215109-2013:TEXT:EN:HTML .. to patrol the external borders of the European Union.
With two very different plans now on the table, each promising the same outcome, it’s worth reminding ourselves of another recommendation of the Expert Panel. In the face of incomplete evidence on asylum issues, the Expert Panel suggested a well-managed and adequately funded research program engaging government and non-government expertise be set up. Without this evidence base, any plan resting on the assumption that asylum-seekers can be out-manoeuvred by deterrents and a social media campaign is doomed to fail. Policies will continue to emerge from left-field as knee jerk reactions to announcements the day before.
Prime Minister Kevin Rudd and Opposition Leader Tony Abbott will still look like contenders fighting the final challenge on the reality show “Survivor”. And most importantly, asylum-seekers fleeing persecution will not be able to access the mechanisms to which they are entitled, to access protection onshore in Australia.
Articles also by This Author
8 October 2013 The Lampedusa asylum tragedy and the lessons for Australia
https://theconversation.com/the-lampedusa-asylum-tragedy-and-the-lessons-for-australia-18980
23 July 2013 Defining ‘success’ in the asylum seeker debate [insert bit]
Survivors of last week’s Lampedusa boat sinking, which is estimated to have left hundreds of African migrants dead. What can Australia learn from the tragedy? EPA/Ettore Ferrari
https://theconversation.com/the-lampedusa-asylum-tragedy-and-the-lessons-for-australia-18980
21 June 2013 From White Australia to stopping the boats: attitudes to asylum seekers
https://theconversation.com/from-white-australia-to-stopping-the-boats-attitudes-to-asylum-seekers-15244
17 May 2013 Out of sight, out of mind: excising Australia from the migration zone
https://theconversation.com/out-of-sight-out-of-mind-excising-australia-from-the-migration-zone-14387
12 April 2013 All the King’s drones won’t stop the boats
https://theconversation.com/all-the-kings-drones-wont-stop-the-boats-13447
https://theconversation.com/tough-guys-operation-sovereign-borders-vs-the-png-solution-16443
27 July 2013, 12.18pm AEST
Just when you thought being “tough on borders” couldn’t get any more serious, along comes the Coalition’s Operation Sovereign Borders. It’s got all the right elements of a plan: it’s an operation (with 12 separate government agencies under the central command of a 3-star general no less), highlights…
Author
Melissa Phillips
Honorary Fellow at University of Melbourne
Disclosure Statement [inside]
[can't reproduce]
Opposition leader Tony Abbott and immigration spokesman Scott
Morrison hope Australian voters prefer their policy. AAP/Dan Peled
Just when you thought being “tough on borders” couldn’t get any more serious, along comes the Coalition’s Operation Sovereign Borders .. http://www.tonyabbott.com.au/LatestNews/PressReleases/tabid/86/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/9311/Operation-Sovereign-Borders.aspx .
It’s got all the right elements of a plan: it’s an operation (with 12 separate government agencies under the central command of a 3-star general no less), highlights the centrality of national sovereignty .. http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-07-25/dunlop-the-only-border-security-we-have-left/4843500 .. and reinforces Howard-era sentiments about border control. So how does it stack up against the Rudd government’s Regional Resettlement Arrangement .. http://www.pm.gov.au/press-office/australia-and-papua-new-guinea-regional-settlement-arrangement ?
Both plans emphasise coordination. Coordination amongst operational agencies was a concern raised earlier by the Expert Panel on Asylum Seekers .. http://expertpanelonasylumseekers.dpmc.gov.au/ . This report focused on the need for coordination in the areas of regional cooperation for protection and asylum frameworks, and strategic dialogue with resettlement countries. It also recommended a whole-of-government approach on engagement with source countries including for the removal and return of failed asylum seekers.
On defence and security matters the Expert Panel suggested the development of joint operational guidelines for managing search and rescue activities in the region and to address the need for any further regional and national codification of arrangements across search and rescue jurisdictions. Even though the Expert Panel was led by Retired Air Marshal Chief Angus Houston, acting Chief of the Defence Force during the “children overboard” incident in 2001, it did not raise coordination between Australian government agencies cooperating on border security as an area in need of improvement.
The highly criticised Regional Resettlement Agreement .. http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jul/26/united-nations-agency-asylum-policy , approaches the issue of asylum seekers from a foreign policy perspective. This is no surprise given Kevin Rudd’s interest in this area and the precedent already set with offshore processing on Manus Island. It links success of the agreement with a possible increase in the offshore humanitarian program to 27,000 places. Under-pinning the whole agreement is an assumption that deterring people from coming to Australia will “send a message” to people trying to seek asylum in Australia. The social media campaign .. http://stream.aljazeera.com/story/201307222149-0022923 .. that accompanied the announcement of the Regional Resettlement Agreement was testimony to this objective.
Opposition Leader Tony Abbott has already been criticised for his alleged lack of diplomatic skills .. http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/federal-election-2013/in-veiled-swipe-at-tony-abbott-png-lashes-australian-politicians-for-impugning-the-dignity-of-its-leaders-20130724-2qj84.html .. when commenting upon the Regional Resettlement Agreement. Unsurprisingly then, Operation Sovereign Borders moves away from the foreign policy domain and presents a defence and security-centric response. It will, through a joint taskforce, allow for the turning back of boats .. http://theconversation.com/explainer-the-legality-of-turning-or-towing-back-asylum-boats-16201 .. where it is safe to do so and the deployment of additional vessels to relieve patrol vessels of passenger transfers. The plan also refers to increasing capacity at offshore processing centres on Manus Island and Nauru.
The Liberal party claims the need for this taskforce is because the “current multiplicity of agencies and reporting lines provides for conflicting strategies, disconnected systems, fractured accountability, inadequate information system, duplication, higher costs and turf wars”. The main evidence presented to support this claim is that of the case of people smuggler Captain Emad .. http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/people-smuggling-suspect-captain-emads-australian-visa-cancelled/story-fn59niix-1226442344176 .. which highlighted issues about cooperation between the Department of Immigration and Australian Federal Police. A commitment remains to regional cooperation on people smuggling through the Bali process. Similar to the Regional Resettlement Agreement, the Operation Sovereign Borders plan .. http://lpaweb-static.s3.amazonaws.com/Policies/OperationSovereignBorders_Policy.pdf , claims it will send a message to people smugglers and their prospective passengers.
Interestingly a similar defence-based option is at the preliminary stage of discussions in Europe for border guards .. http://ted.europa.eu/udl?uri=TED:NOTICE:215109-2013:TEXT:EN:HTML .. to patrol the external borders of the European Union.
With two very different plans now on the table, each promising the same outcome, it’s worth reminding ourselves of another recommendation of the Expert Panel. In the face of incomplete evidence on asylum issues, the Expert Panel suggested a well-managed and adequately funded research program engaging government and non-government expertise be set up. Without this evidence base, any plan resting on the assumption that asylum-seekers can be out-manoeuvred by deterrents and a social media campaign is doomed to fail. Policies will continue to emerge from left-field as knee jerk reactions to announcements the day before.
Prime Minister Kevin Rudd and Opposition Leader Tony Abbott will still look like contenders fighting the final challenge on the reality show “Survivor”. And most importantly, asylum-seekers fleeing persecution will not be able to access the mechanisms to which they are entitled, to access protection onshore in Australia.
Articles also by This Author
8 October 2013 The Lampedusa asylum tragedy and the lessons for Australia
https://theconversation.com/the-lampedusa-asylum-tragedy-and-the-lessons-for-australia-18980
23 July 2013 Defining ‘success’ in the asylum seeker debate [insert bit]
Survivors of last week’s Lampedusa boat sinking, which is estimated to have left hundreds of African migrants dead. What can Australia learn from the tragedy? EPA/Ettore Ferrari
https://theconversation.com/the-lampedusa-asylum-tragedy-and-the-lessons-for-australia-18980
21 June 2013 From White Australia to stopping the boats: attitudes to asylum seekers
https://theconversation.com/from-white-australia-to-stopping-the-boats-attitudes-to-asylum-seekers-15244
17 May 2013 Out of sight, out of mind: excising Australia from the migration zone
https://theconversation.com/out-of-sight-out-of-mind-excising-australia-from-the-migration-zone-14387
12 April 2013 All the King’s drones won’t stop the boats
https://theconversation.com/all-the-kings-drones-wont-stop-the-boats-13447
https://theconversation.com/tough-guys-operation-sovereign-borders-vs-the-png-solution-16443
It was Plato who said, “He, O men, is the wisest, who like Socrates, knows that his wisdom is in truth worth nothing”
Join the InvestorsHub Community
Register for free to join our community of investors and share your ideas. You will also get access to streaming quotes, interactive charts, trades, portfolio, live options flow and more tools.
