Thats still a debate around Denver today.
Keep him or trade em'? Word is Manning isn't too excited about the idea of being a QB/Teacher for Tebow. The Tebow freaks (mostly women) are crying hard today, they see Tebow just as he is, a stand up, good looking young man with great religious beliefs and a strong desire to succeed. All fantastic tangibles but not exactly NFL QB qualities or with natural skills. Tebow has done more for the Denver community than any other athlete in a very short amount of time, yet another great quality. The Tebow fanatics see only those which I mentioned above and they are blind to the fact that this is a business with one goal in mind...... winning the Superbowl ASAP.
IMO the Broncos will shop Tebow who was a first round pick (big mistake) for possible trades that involve filling spots that are needed for a "Manning Type Team" that which includes a couple Wide Receivers, a passing game Tight End and maybe a third down pass catching Running Back. Word is the Broncos are just getting started and there are many more moves on the team roster to be addressed.
Personally, as a 35 year Bronco fan that held season tickets for Elways entire career, I like the move and not once felt Tebow was the QB of the future for Denver. I had a hard time listening/seeing all the hype of last year when the Broncos received more luck in one year than ever before in winning those games while many gave far too much credit directly to Tebow.
I'm optimistic with this Manning deal and wish Tebow "good luck" wherever he may go.