Tuesday, October 17, 2017 9:37:32 PM
Share us on: By Dave Simpson
Law360, New York (October 17, 2017, 8:30 PM EDT) -- A Texas federal judge tacked $137 million in fees and enhanced damages onto a $302 million verdict against Apple Inc. over claims it infringed VirnetX Inc.’s patents through Apple's FaceTime technology.
According to an order unsealed Friday, U.S. District Judge Robert W. Schroeder III increased the damages by $41.3 million, upping the per-device payout for a period during which Apple was found to have willfully infringed the patents. Prior to its trial win in September 2016, VirnetX had beaten Apple twice in court in disputes over the same patents, in November 2012 and February 2016. Both of those jury verdicts were later at least partially overturned. But Judge Schroeder said in the recently unsealed ruling that Apple had become aware of its infringement after the first verdict.
“The court finds that Apple willfully infringed VirnetX’s asserted patents through its continued sales of the accused products containing the infringing VPN on Demand and FaceTime features after the 2012 jury verdict that found the patents infringed and not invalid,” he wrote.
As a result, he increased the damages by 50 percent on units sold after the verdict, from $1.20 to $1.80 per unit.
Additionally, Judge Schroeder approved VirnetX’s request for $96 million in attorneys' fees and costs, citing Apple’s repeated attempts to stay the litigation.
Judge Schroeder said that conflict issues, which arose on the eve of the third trial, also made the case exceptional and justified the expanded attorneys’ fees — Apple hired a jury consultant for the third trial who, it turned out, had worked for VirnetX in the first trial.
Apple told the court that before hiring the consultant, the technology giant had received a statement that he had no conflicts.
“However, Apple’s failure to ensure that its consultant actually had no conflicts unnecessarily complicated the trial,” Judge Schroeder said in his unsealed ruling. “Further, Apple asked the court for several advisory opinions regarding either a potential mistrial or disqualification of counsel because of the conflict, all the while refusing to give VirnetX even basic discovery on the matter.”
Apple had also sought multiple advisory opinions on the possibility for conflict created by VirnetX’s appellate counsel joining Apple’s counsel’s firm, Judge Schroeder said.
“While the court finds nothing improper about VirnetX’s former appellate counsel joining Apple’s counsel’s firm, Apple’s haste in seeking advisory opinions, combined with its delay in providing VirnetX with the relevant facts, demonstrates a level of gamesmanship regarding conflicts it created that the court finds weighs in favor of a finding of an exceptional case,” he said.
VirnetX’s counsel Jason D. Cassady of Caldwell Cassady & Curry lauded his client as being made up of “good, decent people who invented groundbreaking technology."
“It's nice to see good things happen to good people, and we are grateful that the court fully affirmed the jury's verdict,” Cassady said in a release.
The case has a long and expensive history.
After the original, 2010 suit was remanded, Judge Schroeder consolidated it with a case filed in 2012, over Apple’s objections.
Later that year, a jury found that Apple had in fact infringed VirnetX's patents. That finding was partially vacated by the Federal Circuit, which tossed the jury’s $368 million damages award.
In February 2016, a jury again found in favor of VirnetX, this time awarding the patent-holding company $625 million. In July 2016, Judge Schroeder vacated that finding, saying it was unfair to Apple to combine two separate VirnetX suits alleging Apple infringed VirnetX network security patents into one trial. He split the suits and ordered a pair of new trials.
Judge Schroeder also said the jury could have been confused or influenced when at that trial VirnetX referred to the jury’s first infringement ruling in 2012.
In September 2016, after roughly three hours of deliberations, the latest jury found that VirnetX sufficiently showed that Apple’s FaceTime infringed the asserted claims of VirnetX’s U.S. Patent Nos. 7,418,504 and 7,921,211.
VirnetX is represented by Jason D. Cassady of Caldwell Cassady & Curry.
Apple is represented by Joseph A. Loy and Gregory S. Arovas of Kirkland Ellis LLP and Michael E. Jones of Potter Minton.
The case is VirnetX Inc. et al. v. Apple Inc., case number 6:10-cv-00417, in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas.
--Additional reporting by Kelly Knaub. Editing by Edrienne Su.
Recent IDCC News
- InterDigital Announces Financial Results for First Quarter 2024 • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 05/02/2024 12:30:08 PM
- InterDigital awarded injunction against Lenovo • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 05/02/2024 12:30:00 PM
- InterDigital’s Doug Castor Elected Co-Chair of the ATIS Next G Alliance Steering Group • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 04/29/2024 08:00:00 AM
- New Report Pins 6G Success on Novel Benchmarks Extending Beyond Speed, Latency, and Mobility • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 04/25/2024 08:00:00 AM
- InterDigital Announces Date for First Quarter 2024 Financial Results • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 04/19/2024 12:30:00 PM
- InterDigital and Concordia University Announce Research Collaboration on AI-enabled Immersive Media Delivery over 5G Networks • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 04/15/2024 08:00:00 AM
- InterDigital Announces Convertibility of 3.50% Senior Convertible Notes Due 2027 • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 04/04/2024 12:30:00 PM
- InterDigital to Showcase Innovations in High Definition and Sustainable Video Streaming Alongside Partners at NAB 2024 • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 03/26/2024 08:00:00 AM
- InterDigital Declares Regular Quarterly Cash Dividend • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 03/20/2024 08:30:00 PM
- InterDigital’s Xiaofei Wang Appointed Chair of the IEEE 802.11 Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning (AIML) Standing Committee • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 03/20/2024 08:00:00 AM
- Interdigital to Speak at the 36th Annual Roth Conference • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 03/11/2024 12:30:00 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 03/06/2024 09:58:21 PM
- Form 144 - Report of proposed sale of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 03/05/2024 09:03:32 PM
- InterDigital’s Atle Monrad Elected Chair of 3GPP’s SA6 Working Group • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 03/05/2024 09:00:00 AM
- InterDigital Honors Wireless and Video Innovation Leaders Michael Starsinic and Fabrice Le Léannec as Inventors of the Year • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 02/22/2024 09:30:00 PM
- Keysight and InterDigital to Demonstrate AI in 6G Systems at Mobile World Congress 2024 • Business Wire • 02/21/2024 04:00:00 PM
- At MWC, InterDigital to Showcase Innovation Empowering Connected Experiences ‘At Work, At Rest, and At Play’ • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 02/19/2024 09:00:00 AM
- Form 10-K - Annual report [Section 13 and 15(d), not S-K Item 405] • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 02/15/2024 01:37:02 PM
- Form 8-K - Current report • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 02/15/2024 01:33:18 PM
- InterDigital Reports Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2023 Financial Results • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 02/15/2024 01:30:36 PM
- U.S. Futures Edge Higher Ahead of Key Economic Data Release, Oil Prices See Modest Declines • IH Market News • 02/15/2024 11:35:32 AM
- InterDigital and Broadpeak Announce Collaboration on MPEG V3C Standardized Content Distribution At Scale • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 02/13/2024 09:00:00 AM
- InterDigital appoints Ken Kaskoun as Chief Growth Officer • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 02/12/2024 01:30:00 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 02/07/2024 01:43:10 PM
- Form 144 - Report of proposed sale of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 02/05/2024 09:17:26 PM
NanoViricides Reports that the Phase I NV-387 Clinical Trial is Completed Successfully and Data Lock is Expected Soon • NNVC • May 2, 2024 10:07 AM
ILUS Files Form 10-K and Provides Shareholder Update • ILUS • May 2, 2024 8:52 AM
Avant Technologies Names New CEO Following Acquisition of Healthcare Technology and Data Integration Firm • AVAI • May 2, 2024 8:00 AM
Bantec Engaged in a Letter of Intent to Acquire a Small New Jersey Based Manufacturing Company • BANT • May 1, 2024 10:00 AM
Cannabix Technologies to Deliver Breath Logix Alcohol Screening Device to Australia • BLO • Apr 30, 2024 8:53 AM
Hydromer, Inc. Reports Preliminary Unaudited Financial Results for First Quarter 2024 • HYDI • Apr 29, 2024 9:10 AM