AMERICAN IDOL

[ONEBGG]

Top 4 to 3

Rayvon - Want To Want Me:Good song choice, but still limited by his range and again much the same. Grade B-.

As: Again I was not impressed. However, nice to see him not swallowing the mic so much. Grade B-.

You Are So Beautiful: Interesting attempt; I can't figure out what the crowd is hearing, but I didn't like it. Grade D.

Clark - Beautiful Day: I think Scott may have set him up for failure on this. Clark pulled this off, but it was just okay, but the crowd sure likes it; maybe I'm just old and stodgy. Grade B.

Sittin' On The Dock Of The Bay: Now this is what Clark does best, but still, coming from Clark I expected more on this song, but still well done. Grade A-.

Earned It: Great song choice! He looked good and he did the song justice - Clark Is Back!!! Grade A+!

Nick - Because The Night: Never liked this song, so I may not be a good judge on this one. I did not like it, again I don't what the crowd is listening to. Grade C. "The Judges Like It?!)

Back Home: Another good attempt, but the word attempt says it all. Again, I just can't figure out what the crowd is listening - do they put something in the water? Not too impressed. Grade B-.

I'll Be: Not bad, he is getting better, but I still find him a bit average. Grade B. (Again, The crowd & the judges liked it?!!!)

Jax - My Generation: I have never been a fan of this song, but this is the best I have heard it covered. Grade A-.

My Immortal: I really liked this. Jax has an interesting voice, she can be breathy, mousy, gentle or strong, it's all good. She has a genuine style of her own. Grade A.

Misery Business: Don't like song, but Jax did well with it. Grade B.

Went Home: Nick or Rayvon!

Well, Rayvon got sent home; no surprise here, I believe we all expected this, and many of us thought much sooner. He has always been a one-trick-pony.

My Thoughts: I have thought Clark had this season in the bag from the start, but at this point I think it is going to be close between Clark & Jax; maybe Clark's cover of Earned It will have saved him.

The Winner: I can't be sure at this point, I think it will probably be Clark, but would not be surprised at all if it is Jax. However, I will be shocked if it is Nick. In fact, if it is Nick I would consider this highly suspect.