AMERICAN IDOL

[gail]

skilz, once again...............................

..

you beat me to the review.

i forget skilz, if you said if you take notes DURING their singing, vs after the judges comment. sometimes, judges can sway an opinion.

we agree on some tonight, and differ on some, here's my take.......

Girls night...

1- tyanna- ouch, flat, had the slow "old lady" type vibrato and doesnt fit the super fun song she did (rockin' robin). but she didnt mess up the (tons) of lyrics in that song, fast paced. judges loved it.

2- loren- the song sounded a lot like "the love boat" theme with the band and all. a bit cheesy for me. but she is so sweet and positive. cute outfit. her one high note was off, but loved the rest. judges loved her.

3- maddie- beautiful young lady, spot on key imo. but looked very nervous. made me feel nervous for her. she should have changed the song up some, yet, jaylo said she loved how she changed it. hmmm. her last note was off key otherwise, imo.

4- joey (from my old stomping grounds, woodbridge, va) but she is a mess. maybe on something, not sure. still not acting serious, just being goofy, too quirky, freaked out and hyper.

5- sarina- I got double "goosies" (goose bumps), loved it! but, OMG HARRY SAID SHE WAS FLAT???

6- adanna- she was about to fall out of her dress, yipes. but whatever. anyway.. I love the song "hello" in general. i heard just ONE flat spot but her song made me teary. she felt it and i felt it. BUT AGAIN HARRY SAID THE WHOLE SONG WAS OUT OF TUNE? maybe he has an inner ear thing this week. i think he has lost it. all the judges killed it with their comments. Skilz, even you didnt like it. i LOVED it. very moving and great imo.

7- jax- she totally changed "no mountain high enough" so much, that i thought she was about to do "fever". but i LOVED it. the judges hated how much she changed it. Skilz, we are in agreement here, about how we loved that change. the vocals were good, but not exciting. and then i was thinking "is that the blue/gold/etc" dress that was all over the internet? then i died laughing when ryan came over and asked that. haha!!!

8- alexis- the country style girl. YUCK! worst of the night (so i see that we agree on that too Skilz). I hated the barefoot thing but the hippy judge commented that he loved it. haha, omg. the judges otherwise, ripped into her. she's gone. (i hope)