Loop, can you explain why you would think Nokia would put in its complaint, the article from Forbes as support for their claim? To this non lawyer, by Nokia using that article, it opens up the possibility that IDCC's attorney's can then use the numerous articles out their against Nokia who has been accused of price fixing by some reporters in their attempt to get a cap on royalties, in addition to other misdeeds. I would think quoting an article from Forbes is a stretch at best, as "proof" of what you are claiming but now that Nokia has used this tactic, IDCC should respond in kind IMO and cite all the articles that accuse Nokia of wrongdoing of whatever kind. I bet if we gave OLDDOG 15 minutes, he could come up with several pages worth of links to articles that would shed Nokia in not the best light. What do you think?