Never said that should be a stickied either. However, that could at least have a chance to be verified, although unlikely, by others calling and claiming their results. The claims are based on testimony of what they were told and not opinion.
I agree with people stating we should refrain from such actions and let them do their job. Also, the phone call post wasn't formulated just to attack SANP, the CEO's, or the intelligence of investors to have the ability to make their own decisions like this OP.
In the end, no, neither should be stickied by their own merits alone.