AMERICAN IDOL

[gail]

just watched and here is my take..........

..

also, skilz, i wanted to ask you.. do you take notes of how they did BEFORE the judges comment? i do, so that im not swayed. you know?

ok, here we go..

in order of singers..

gena- blah

alex- yuck

jessica- flat and that is too bad, i liked her, but ouch.

dexter- good but not super.. still too twangy for me.

emily- yuck, sorry.

caleb- omg, he rocked it again, but just not as good as last week BUT he sings like a man, and the mousy men (i hope) will want to sing more like him. he is bringing rock back and the young audience was like "whats that great sound?".

Ms. Mk- yucko! nice tone to her voice but sorry, it was awful.

cj- pitchy, above the keys, i do like him, but it was not good.

sam- i liked it. nice folk singer vibe going on there.

malaya- too churchy and super pitchy but it seems people got caught up in that hype. ??

ben- i was on the fence but it just wasnt good. i wanted to like it but.. no.

magesty- started off good and tanked, kind of like so many penny stocks after super news.