Swi here is the primary difference.
Individuals who praise Floyd Smith and his performance are repeating relying and basing all of it on his promises that, as of today, has never been materialized in any shape and form. Currently, the only promise left that everybody is clinging to is S1 approval. But in general it is all about "future plans, great things to come, pumping oil some time in the future"........
Individuals who criticize Floyd Smith and his performance solely rely, provide and repeat easily verifiable facts including Bakken bust, dilution, missed deadlines and broken promises..........
Everybody repeats their narratives but one side repeats "grand future plans to come " and the other confirmed and veritable facts that took place.
IMHO